How does air intake work in Kerbal Space Program?

[BACK]
How does air intake work in Kerbal Space Program?
Posted On: April 3, 2023

I've just started building planes and am confused about the way air intake works. For instance, the J-90 "Goliath" Turbofan Engine is specified to consume a whopping 132.272 Air/sec while supplying Intake Air: 3.4 (presumably this is per second as well?).


How would I supply such an engine, let alone two?


The largest supplier of air that I can find seems to be the Engine Nacelle with Intake Air: 5.0 (similarly the Engine Pre-Cooler that takes in the same amount but is more expensive and lighter). That means, if I want to supply one Goliath, I'd need about 26 Nacelles, or 65 Radial Air Intakes (which claim to provide`Intake Air: 2.0). Presumably this is the maximum intake ASL, which supposedly drops higher in atmo (and probably depends on speed). So this doesn't sound like the correct way to determine air requirements.


So: How do I translate the Intake Air figure I see in the Item description to the usable amount of air/sec that I have available for my engines?


Question from user bitmask at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

First, differentiate between intake air use/production, and intake air storage. It's a resource similar to electric energy or monopropellant. It's scooped by the intakes, stored in "tanks" provided by the intakes and drawn by engines from these "tanks". And since you're not supposed to be able to take a good supply of intake air to the orbit, the "tanks" provided are of puny size. Engine Nacelle can store 5 units of intake air, but it can scoop much, much more than that per second.


I can't give you a precise answer how to find out the rates, just - don't overthink it and don't worry. In most cases 1 intake (any) per engine is aplenty, 1 per 2 engines is sufficient. The primary practical difference is in aerodynamic properties, that is how much drag it causes - e.g. circular intakes are bad for supersonic flight. .


Thing is, the amount of intake air changes with atmospheric density, and that changes with altitude - exponentially (it also depends on airspeed and the intake area facing "into the wind" so if you mount your intakes backwards - or your plane turns tail-forward - you may face air starvation). At altitudes up to 20km you'll have to fail pretty hard to starve your engine of air. Above that - around 24-26km - there's an altitude threshold at which air becomes too thin and your engines are starved of air. Note the exponential nature of pressure makes the threshold hit hard; you can do very little about shifting it. You may push maybe a kilometer up through use of plenty intakes, but it's not really worth it (the extra drag from the added intakes will contribute more negatively than the extra flight altitude will benefit you).


There's a plenty of other "hidden" characteristics of the jet engine, like airspeed-thrust curve, pressure-thrust curve, etc. Goliaths are, for example, subsonic engines which really lose power at higher speeds, and won't allow for extreme altitudes either. And they have intakes big and efficient enough that it's very hard to starve them of air - you'll run out of thrust long before you reach altitude where their intakes can't keep up with the consumption. .


Answer from user SF. at gaming.stackexchange.com.



[BACK]
How does air intake work in Kerbal Space Program?
Posted On: April 3, 2023

I've just started building planes and am confused about the way air intake works. For instance, the J-90 "Goliath" Turbofan Engine is specified to consume a whopping 132.272 Air/sec while supplying Intake Air: 3.4 (presumably this is per second as well?).


How would I supply such an engine, let alone two?


The largest supplier of air that I can find seems to be the Engine Nacelle with Intake Air: 5.0 (similarly the Engine Pre-Cooler that takes in the same amount but is more expensive and lighter). That means, if I want to supply one Goliath, I'd need about 26 Nacelles, or 65 Radial Air Intakes (which claim to provide`Intake Air: 2.0). Presumably this is the maximum intake ASL, which supposedly drops higher in atmo (and probably depends on speed). So this doesn't sound like the correct way to determine air requirements.


So: How do I translate the Intake Air figure I see in the Item description to the usable amount of air/sec that I have available for my engines?


Question from user bitmask at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

First, differentiate between intake air use/production, and intake air storage. It's a resource similar to electric energy or monopropellant. It's scooped by the intakes, stored in "tanks" provided by the intakes and drawn by engines from these "tanks". And since you're not supposed to be able to take a good supply of intake air to the orbit, the "tanks" provided are of puny size. Engine Nacelle can store 5 units of intake air, but it can scoop much, much more than that per second.


I can't give you a precise answer how to find out the rates, just - don't overthink it and don't worry. In most cases 1 intake (any) per engine is aplenty, 1 per 2 engines is sufficient. The primary practical difference is in aerodynamic properties, that is how much drag it causes - e.g. circular intakes are bad for supersonic flight. .


Thing is, the amount of intake air changes with atmospheric density, and that changes with altitude - exponentially (it also depends on airspeed and the intake area facing "into the wind" so if you mount your intakes backwards - or your plane turns tail-forward - you may face air starvation). At altitudes up to 20km you'll have to fail pretty hard to starve your engine of air. Above that - around 24-26km - there's an altitude threshold at which air becomes too thin and your engines are starved of air. Note the exponential nature of pressure makes the threshold hit hard; you can do very little about shifting it. You may push maybe a kilometer up through use of plenty intakes, but it's not really worth it (the extra drag from the added intakes will contribute more negatively than the extra flight altitude will benefit you).


There's a plenty of other "hidden" characteristics of the jet engine, like airspeed-thrust curve, pressure-thrust curve, etc. Goliaths are, for example, subsonic engines which really lose power at higher speeds, and won't allow for extreme altitudes either. And they have intakes big and efficient enough that it's very hard to starve them of air - you'll run out of thrust long before you reach altitude where their intakes can't keep up with the consumption. .


Answer from user SF. at gaming.stackexchange.com.



[BACK]

Where can I find pearls in Witcher 3? Where can I find pearls in Witcher 3?

Posted On: March 5, 2023
I am playing Witcher 3 from after patch 1.05. Is it possible to buy shells (pearls) from a merchant, or do I have to find them somewhere? Question from user Purple Rabbit at gaming.stackexchange...[More]


Where is Alice in Kingdom Hearts? Where is Alice in Kingdom Hearts?

Posted On: February 27, 2023
Apparently I have to find Alice, because she has gone missing and you can't have a trial without a defendant (or so says the Queen, and I am going to take her at her word, because I don't want...[More]


What is the True Ending in Hogwarts Legacy? What is the True Ending in Hogwarts Legacy?

Posted On: July 19, 2023
What is the True Ending in Hogwarts Legacy after you've completed the main storyline? The answer in this question explains the main storyline endings, but I'm looking for the so-called &quo...[More]


Tell me why I should like Minsc Tell me why I should like Minsc

Posted On: September 27, 2023
Because he’s the first person at camp that I don’t like (well except Mizora). I don’t like his character and at this point I don’t really. Red a ranger. Question from user B...[More]


How do I find my Outpost(s)? How do I find my Outpost(s)?

Posted On: September 6, 2023
In my adventures I found a planet that had an iron deposit, which I need a lot of. I placed down the outpost marker, miner, and powered up. Then I went on my way with other interstellar adventures. I&...[More]


What are some tactics to fortify villages and their population against outside attack? What are some tactics to fortify villages and their population against outside attack?

Posted On: January 29, 2023
I recently discovered my homely village has been ransacked by a marauding horde of zombies. They managed to get inside one of my large apartment houses and wiped out all but two (!) of the village pop...[More]


Agitated Giant Thrips: how to properly deal with them in Dwarf Fortress? Agitated Giant Thrips: how to properly deal with them in Dwarf Fortress?

Posted On: April 25, 2023
The number one cause of death on my Fortress is: attack by flying insects. As they don't activate the Cage Traps, because they don't touch the ground, which are the possible ways to deal wi...[More]


How much room do I need to play Ring Fit Adventure? How much room do I need to play Ring Fit Adventure?

Posted On: April 8, 2024
I'm interested in Ring Fit Adventure, but given the layout of my room, I have a relatively narrow strip of space between the Dresser/TV and the end of my bed. Is this enough room to successfully perfo...[More]


How do I replay the credits mini game? How do I replay the credits mini game?

Posted On: December 1, 2023
Is there a way to replay the credits minigame in Super Mario Bros Wonder? I want to aim for a new high score, but I'd like to avoid replaying the final stage for every attempt. Question from us...[More]


How can I disable use of a macro if a spell is on cooldown? How can I disable use of a macro if a spell is on cooldown?

Posted On: January 29, 2023
As a Shadow Priest, I use a macro to announce to those nearby who I'm casting Power Infusion on. I do this for clarity in a raid and Mythic+ setting. It works fairly well.The problem I'm encountering ...[More]