How does air intake work in Kerbal Space Program?

[BACK]
How does air intake work in Kerbal Space Program?
Posted On: April 3, 2023

I've just started building planes and am confused about the way air intake works. For instance, the J-90 "Goliath" Turbofan Engine is specified to consume a whopping 132.272 Air/sec while supplying Intake Air: 3.4 (presumably this is per second as well?).


How would I supply such an engine, let alone two?


The largest supplier of air that I can find seems to be the Engine Nacelle with Intake Air: 5.0 (similarly the Engine Pre-Cooler that takes in the same amount but is more expensive and lighter). That means, if I want to supply one Goliath, I'd need about 26 Nacelles, or 65 Radial Air Intakes (which claim to provide`Intake Air: 2.0). Presumably this is the maximum intake ASL, which supposedly drops higher in atmo (and probably depends on speed). So this doesn't sound like the correct way to determine air requirements.


So: How do I translate the Intake Air figure I see in the Item description to the usable amount of air/sec that I have available for my engines?


Question from user bitmask at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

First, differentiate between intake air use/production, and intake air storage. It's a resource similar to electric energy or monopropellant. It's scooped by the intakes, stored in "tanks" provided by the intakes and drawn by engines from these "tanks". And since you're not supposed to be able to take a good supply of intake air to the orbit, the "tanks" provided are of puny size. Engine Nacelle can store 5 units of intake air, but it can scoop much, much more than that per second.


I can't give you a precise answer how to find out the rates, just - don't overthink it and don't worry. In most cases 1 intake (any) per engine is aplenty, 1 per 2 engines is sufficient. The primary practical difference is in aerodynamic properties, that is how much drag it causes - e.g. circular intakes are bad for supersonic flight. .


Thing is, the amount of intake air changes with atmospheric density, and that changes with altitude - exponentially (it also depends on airspeed and the intake area facing "into the wind" so if you mount your intakes backwards - or your plane turns tail-forward - you may face air starvation). At altitudes up to 20km you'll have to fail pretty hard to starve your engine of air. Above that - around 24-26km - there's an altitude threshold at which air becomes too thin and your engines are starved of air. Note the exponential nature of pressure makes the threshold hit hard; you can do very little about shifting it. You may push maybe a kilometer up through use of plenty intakes, but it's not really worth it (the extra drag from the added intakes will contribute more negatively than the extra flight altitude will benefit you).


There's a plenty of other "hidden" characteristics of the jet engine, like airspeed-thrust curve, pressure-thrust curve, etc. Goliaths are, for example, subsonic engines which really lose power at higher speeds, and won't allow for extreme altitudes either. And they have intakes big and efficient enough that it's very hard to starve them of air - you'll run out of thrust long before you reach altitude where their intakes can't keep up with the consumption. .


Answer from user SF. at gaming.stackexchange.com.



[BACK]
How does air intake work in Kerbal Space Program?
Posted On: April 3, 2023

I've just started building planes and am confused about the way air intake works. For instance, the J-90 "Goliath" Turbofan Engine is specified to consume a whopping 132.272 Air/sec while supplying Intake Air: 3.4 (presumably this is per second as well?).


How would I supply such an engine, let alone two?


The largest supplier of air that I can find seems to be the Engine Nacelle with Intake Air: 5.0 (similarly the Engine Pre-Cooler that takes in the same amount but is more expensive and lighter). That means, if I want to supply one Goliath, I'd need about 26 Nacelles, or 65 Radial Air Intakes (which claim to provide`Intake Air: 2.0). Presumably this is the maximum intake ASL, which supposedly drops higher in atmo (and probably depends on speed). So this doesn't sound like the correct way to determine air requirements.


So: How do I translate the Intake Air figure I see in the Item description to the usable amount of air/sec that I have available for my engines?


Question from user bitmask at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

First, differentiate between intake air use/production, and intake air storage. It's a resource similar to electric energy or monopropellant. It's scooped by the intakes, stored in "tanks" provided by the intakes and drawn by engines from these "tanks". And since you're not supposed to be able to take a good supply of intake air to the orbit, the "tanks" provided are of puny size. Engine Nacelle can store 5 units of intake air, but it can scoop much, much more than that per second.


I can't give you a precise answer how to find out the rates, just - don't overthink it and don't worry. In most cases 1 intake (any) per engine is aplenty, 1 per 2 engines is sufficient. The primary practical difference is in aerodynamic properties, that is how much drag it causes - e.g. circular intakes are bad for supersonic flight. .


Thing is, the amount of intake air changes with atmospheric density, and that changes with altitude - exponentially (it also depends on airspeed and the intake area facing "into the wind" so if you mount your intakes backwards - or your plane turns tail-forward - you may face air starvation). At altitudes up to 20km you'll have to fail pretty hard to starve your engine of air. Above that - around 24-26km - there's an altitude threshold at which air becomes too thin and your engines are starved of air. Note the exponential nature of pressure makes the threshold hit hard; you can do very little about shifting it. You may push maybe a kilometer up through use of plenty intakes, but it's not really worth it (the extra drag from the added intakes will contribute more negatively than the extra flight altitude will benefit you).


There's a plenty of other "hidden" characteristics of the jet engine, like airspeed-thrust curve, pressure-thrust curve, etc. Goliaths are, for example, subsonic engines which really lose power at higher speeds, and won't allow for extreme altitudes either. And they have intakes big and efficient enough that it's very hard to starve them of air - you'll run out of thrust long before you reach altitude where their intakes can't keep up with the consumption. .


Answer from user SF. at gaming.stackexchange.com.



[BACK]

Starcraft II - How to play 1v1 on local LAN Starcraft II - How to play 1v1 on local LAN

Posted On: March 3, 2023
I'm happy LAN play is available. But, I want to play 1v1 instead of 2vX cooperative. If I have the other player in a party, I'm able to try to start a 1v1 game, and my partner is able to accep...[More]


Dark Souls 3, How do I kill the Abyss Watchers? Dark Souls 3, How do I kill the Abyss Watchers?

Posted On: May 21, 2023
I have been trying so hard for a week and I can't figure out how to kill these guys. I can finish off the first phase but no matter how hard I try, I can't kill the fire dude! Does anyone k...[More]


Are the Poker Night games rigged? Are the Poker Night games rigged?

Posted On: February 7, 2023
I've played poker in real life and I've played Poker Night at the Inventory (but not Poker Night 2). I have the feeling that the Poker Night engine manipulates the deck to give players a mo...[More]


Why do I create 2 characters when starting a new playthrough? Why do I create 2 characters when starting a new playthrough?

Posted On: August 8, 2023
The character creation process is very confusing to me. I know it's early access and things are being polished continuously, but it's unclear why I need to create 2 characters. After comple...[More]


In Farmville, Can I make friends with people who arent my social media friends? In Farmville, Can I make friends with people who arent my social media friends?

Posted On: May 25, 2023
I want friends! Friends seem awesome! I have a couple through people I know on Facebook, but not a lot of people I know are playing this game. Can I make friends any other way than connecting my socia...[More]


What does Ominis mean when he says Imelda's quick and not just on a broom? What does Ominis mean when he says Imelda's quick and not just on a broom?

Posted On: July 19, 2023
he says it so cheeky as if it's an insult but the only insulting meaning for quick really only applies to guys and even then generally quick means witty and/or smart. am I misreading his voice or ...[More]


Does Hogwarts Legacy have multiple endings? Does Hogwarts Legacy have multiple endings?

Posted On: March 13, 2023
I am planning to replay Hogwarts Legacy after I've completed current story, but if there is multiple endings, I think I'm going to try this game out without learning the unforgivable curses. S...[More]


Are there enemies immune to quickhacks in Cyberpunk 2077? Are there enemies immune to quickhacks in Cyberpunk 2077?

Posted On: May 20, 2023
I'm pretty deep into the game, relying on quickhacks for damage so far, and I've yet to encounter enemies immune to quickhacks entirely. This seems to indicate that I don't need any other ...[More]


In Pokemon Go does the Vivilion postcard pinning overflow to the next medal? In Pokemon Go does the Vivilion postcard pinning overflow to the next medal?

Posted On: March 3, 2023
If I have a Vivilion medal at 12 out of 15 and then pins 5 postcards for that model, would the medal be completed and the left over of 2 be brought over to the next medal? Or would the new medal st...[More]


What does Johnny say if youve not completed Blistering Love prior to starting Nocturne Op55N1? What does Johnny say if youve not completed Blistering Love prior to starting Nocturne Op55N1?

Posted On: March 15, 2024
This question is about an option near the end of Cyberpunk 2077. There are certain side quests that, if completed, provide extra options to finishing the last quest. What does Johnny say if those side...[More]