Is shoving enemies supposed to make you an oath breaker?

[BACK]
Is shoving enemies supposed to make you an oath breaker?
Posted On: June 9, 2025

I'm confused. Got into a conflict in act one with zarys and her goons. They initiate combat and my paladin shoved one of them off a cliff. Immediate oathbreaker. I reloaded and just killed them normally and no oathbreaker. Any ideas why? Can I just not throw/shove enemies?


Question from user JustsomeOKCguy at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


Answer:

Would you look at that, aparently it does, from the wiki for Oath of the Ancients (im guessing this is your oath right?).


Shoving someone to their death also counts as breaking the Oath. This sometimes also includes evil characters, such as Assassins of Bhaal in Orins arena.


I was going to guess that you accidentaly killed the artist down on the pit, but I checked the wiki just in case, never would have guessed that one lol.


Answer from user Gasurza22 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


[BACK]
Is shoving enemies supposed to make you an oath breaker?
Posted On: June 9, 2025

I'm confused. Got into a conflict in act one with zarys and her goons. They initiate combat and my paladin shoved one of them off a cliff. Immediate oathbreaker. I reloaded and just killed them normally and no oathbreaker. Any ideas why? Can I just not throw/shove enemies?


Question from user JustsomeOKCguy at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


Answer:

Would you look at that, aparently it does, from the wiki for Oath of the Ancients (im guessing this is your oath right?).


Shoving someone to their death also counts as breaking the Oath. This sometimes also includes evil characters, such as Assassins of Bhaal in Orins arena.


I was going to guess that you accidentaly killed the artist down on the pit, but I checked the wiki just in case, never would have guessed that one lol.


Answer from user Gasurza22 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


[BACK]

Can you cast a Patronus Charm in Hogwarts Legacy? Can you cast a Patronus Charm in Hogwarts Legacy?

Posted On: July 19, 2023
Is it possible to use the Patronus Charm in Hogwarts Legacy? If yes, then where and how? Question from user Shaun Roselt at stackexchange. Answer: No. According to an article on videogamer...[More]


Why are expected delivery times given as a range? Why are expected delivery times given as a range?

Posted On: January 22, 2023
On the "Current job" screen in the Route Advisor, the expected delivery time is always given as a range, e.g. "Fri 21:50 - Sat 2:00".Why is that? I know the second time is the actual deadline and if y...[More]


How to mark items as junk in The Outer Worlds? How to mark items as junk in The Outer Worlds?

Posted On: May 2, 2023
Items you've marked as Junk can be sold in bulk. Okay, so how do I mark items as junk? There is no UI in the game or anything else, just a tip that suggests that you can mark items as junk. ...[More]


Cannot beat this fight to save my life, help? Cannot beat this fight to save my life, help?

Posted On: March 29, 2025
I’m at the Kethric/Myrkul fight and I am getting my ass beat. Level 8 Warlock main with Shadowheart on support, Karlach as melee, and Gale as range/distraction. .I’ve read the tips, I go free Nigh...[More]


What's the Path of Least Resistance for Honor Mode? What's the Path of Least Resistance for Honor Mode?

Posted On: November 11, 2025
I really wanna get it done, I know the basics, talk down Lump and the goblins in the village, wander around and get Karlach, free Slazza, what's everything that you should be doing to get high enough ...[More]


Poppy - Natsai Quest? Poppy - Natsai Quest?

Posted On: June 18, 2023
Good evening!. I have a short question: when do the quests from Poppy/Natsai continue? I got to the quest: "The Poachers House Call" with Poppy and to "Mum's the Word" with ...[More]


Does losing to Natsai in the first Charms class matter? Does losing to Natsai in the first Charms class matter?

Posted On: August 11, 2023
Does losing against her make any difference. Also did you win or lose against her your first time? Question from user Kronik95 at HogwartsLegacyGaming at reddit. Answer: I lost to her on m...[More]


What Pokemon characteristics are immutable as of gen 9 games? What Pokemon characteristics are immutable as of gen 9 games?

Posted On: February 6, 2023
I'm picking up Pokemon games with Violet and learning about every additions made to the game since gen 2, I'm having a hard time figuring out what are the Pokemon characteristics you can't change thro...[More]


Reach the compartment before it closes in Agent A: A Puzzle in Disguise Reach the compartment before it closes in Agent A: A Puzzle in Disguise

Posted On: July 9, 2023
In chapter 3, there is a button on the ground to the right of a platform in the center of the room. Clicking the button opened a compartment on the left side of the platform. The compartment keeps clo...[More]


What is it and where can I find or take those holopics in Gamedec? What is it and where can I find or take those holopics in Gamedec?

Posted On: February 17, 2023
During the Knight's Code mission, there is a faulty NPC that you have to fix or kill. If you try to expose her, she will give you a job. You have to collect those two holopics. I have sea...[More]