Is shoving enemies supposed to make you an oath breaker?

[BACK]
Is shoving enemies supposed to make you an oath breaker?
Posted On: June 9, 2025

I'm confused. Got into a conflict in act one with zarys and her goons. They initiate combat and my paladin shoved one of them off a cliff. Immediate oathbreaker. I reloaded and just killed them normally and no oathbreaker. Any ideas why? Can I just not throw/shove enemies?


Question from user JustsomeOKCguy at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


Answer:

Would you look at that, aparently it does, from the wiki for Oath of the Ancients (im guessing this is your oath right?).


Shoving someone to their death also counts as breaking the Oath. This sometimes also includes evil characters, such as Assassins of Bhaal in Orins arena.


I was going to guess that you accidentaly killed the artist down on the pit, but I checked the wiki just in case, never would have guessed that one lol.


Answer from user Gasurza22 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


[BACK]
Is shoving enemies supposed to make you an oath breaker?
Posted On: June 9, 2025

I'm confused. Got into a conflict in act one with zarys and her goons. They initiate combat and my paladin shoved one of them off a cliff. Immediate oathbreaker. I reloaded and just killed them normally and no oathbreaker. Any ideas why? Can I just not throw/shove enemies?


Question from user JustsomeOKCguy at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


Answer:

Would you look at that, aparently it does, from the wiki for Oath of the Ancients (im guessing this is your oath right?).


Shoving someone to their death also counts as breaking the Oath. This sometimes also includes evil characters, such as Assassins of Bhaal in Orins arena.


I was going to guess that you accidentaly killed the artist down on the pit, but I checked the wiki just in case, never would have guessed that one lol.


Answer from user Gasurza22 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


[BACK]

How do you get to these chests in Hogwarts Legacy? How do you get to these chests in Hogwarts Legacy?

Posted On: August 22, 2023
In the gatehouse of the High Keep you can see a loft and Revelio reveals some chests up there but I can’t figure out how to reach them. It looks like you should be able to climb this pile of cra...[More]


What's the worst way to re-class every companion? What's the worst way to re-class every companion?

Posted On: October 16, 2025
Everyone talks about the best way. .What would be the worst and/or most unhinged classes to give each companion. .My favorite would be making Minthara a Wizard.Question from user kikicandraw at Baldur...[More]


How to mark items as junk in The Outer Worlds? How to mark items as junk in The Outer Worlds?

Posted On: May 2, 2023
Items you've marked as Junk can be sold in bulk. Okay, so how do I mark items as junk? There is no UI in the game or anything else, just a tip that suggests that you can mark items as junk. ...[More]


Is there any reward for collecting stamps in Super Mario 3D World? Is there any reward for collecting stamps in Super Mario 3D World?

Posted On: August 15, 2023
While playing Super Mario 3D World I've been collecting stamps throughout various levels, but far from all of them. Still, I've gathered a decent amount, and as far as I can tell there hasn...[More]


How can I recover a Microsoft account using my Minecraft username? How can I recover a Microsoft account using my Minecraft username?

Posted On: February 28, 2023
When I tried to open Minecraft today, it asked me to sign into a Microsoft account. I do not remember the email and password for the account I used to buy Minecraft. I have already tried entering m...[More]


Hogwarts Legacy Collectors Edition Trophy Troubles Hogwarts Legacy Collectors Edition Trophy Troubles

Posted On: March 10, 2023
So I am trying to Platinum the game and I hace finally got all of the collections completed but I still don't have the trophy. The trophy says I only have 602/603, am I missing something? Does any...[More]


Existence of different Super Mario World versions Existence of different Super Mario World versions

Posted On: January 26, 2023
Years ago, I had an argument with a friend about the colors of the Yoshis in Super Mario World. I claimed them to be green, red, yellow, and blue; my friend argued that the colors were green, red, yel...[More]


Tactical stance in COD MW3 - is there RL equivalent? Tactical stance in COD MW3 - is there RL equivalent?

Posted On: January 19, 2024
The new tactical stance in COD MW3 - is it based on reality? I can't imagine why holding a weapon tilted would give you an advantage in combat. Any insight? Question from user Boppity Bop at st...[More]


Neds Island weapon slots and backpack SDU in DLC Neds Island weapon slots and backpack SDU in DLC

Posted On: March 24, 2023
I have started playing Ned's Island. Will I unlock all weapon slots and backpack slots without completing original content? Question from user Dmitry Mukhin at gaming.stackexchange.com. Answ...[More]


Should I turn in sebastion in Hogwarts Legacy? Should I turn in sebastion in Hogwarts Legacy?

Posted On: March 16, 2023
I already learned Avada Kedavra so there's no point for me to keep him around just wondering if there are any underlining consequences to doing so, plus he does say whatever happens he's glad ...[More]