Is shoving enemies supposed to make you an oath breaker?

[BACK]
Is shoving enemies supposed to make you an oath breaker?
Posted On: June 9, 2025

I'm confused. Got into a conflict in act one with zarys and her goons. They initiate combat and my paladin shoved one of them off a cliff. Immediate oathbreaker. I reloaded and just killed them normally and no oathbreaker. Any ideas why? Can I just not throw/shove enemies?


Question from user JustsomeOKCguy at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


Answer:

Would you look at that, aparently it does, from the wiki for Oath of the Ancients (im guessing this is your oath right?).


Shoving someone to their death also counts as breaking the Oath. This sometimes also includes evil characters, such as Assassins of Bhaal in Orins arena.


I was going to guess that you accidentaly killed the artist down on the pit, but I checked the wiki just in case, never would have guessed that one lol.


Answer from user Gasurza22 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


[BACK]
Is shoving enemies supposed to make you an oath breaker?
Posted On: June 9, 2025

I'm confused. Got into a conflict in act one with zarys and her goons. They initiate combat and my paladin shoved one of them off a cliff. Immediate oathbreaker. I reloaded and just killed them normally and no oathbreaker. Any ideas why? Can I just not throw/shove enemies?


Question from user JustsomeOKCguy at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


Answer:

Would you look at that, aparently it does, from the wiki for Oath of the Ancients (im guessing this is your oath right?).


Shoving someone to their death also counts as breaking the Oath. This sometimes also includes evil characters, such as Assassins of Bhaal in Orins arena.


I was going to guess that you accidentaly killed the artist down on the pit, but I checked the wiki just in case, never would have guessed that one lol.


Answer from user Gasurza22 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


[BACK]

Yurgir Fight Yurgir Fight

Posted On: December 16, 2024
This is a tip for fighting Yurgir in the Shar Temple. I tried fighting him a half dozen times and died each time. The combination of creatures aiding him and the grenades took me out too quickly. The ...[More]


Play DLC witch physical copy on the Switch Play DLC witch physical copy on the Switch

Posted On: January 18, 2023
I bought a physical copy of Civilization VI for the switch. I'm pondering if I should buy the DLC, ("Gathering Storm" and "Rise & Fall"). . Now I'm concerned about a...[More]


Can I progress without doing isobel’s fight encounter? Can I progress without doing isobel’s fight encounter?

Posted On: November 25, 2023
I think I’ve reloaded my save 6 or 7 times trying to save this & I can’t for the life of me make it happen. I think the closest I’ve gotten has been getting Marcus down to like 3...[More]


Rocket League controller only works on Press Any Button to Start screen Rocket League controller only works on Press Any Button to Start screen

Posted On: September 17, 2023
When I start Rocket League, I press a button on my controller at the screen that says "Press Any Button to Start". That brings up the main menu, but my controller no longer works to control ...[More]


Why isnt Diep.io loading? Why isnt Diep.io loading?

Posted On: February 2, 2023
I have just got on to diep.io, and it is stuck on the "Connecting" screen. The tab also keeps refreshing. I see many errors on my developer tools when I press the F12 key.I am using a Windows 10 Surfa...[More]


What do you use Luxury gemstones for in Slipways? What do you use Luxury gemstones for in Slipways?

Posted On: June 24, 2023
Starting a new game, I got a Gemstone Asteroids modifier. I quickly found the a gemstone asteroid and managed to mine it. But I can't figure out what they are good for? Question from user DJ...[More]


Avoiding detection while hacking the computer in one step ahead Avoiding detection while hacking the computer in one step ahead

Posted On: October 22, 2023
I'm on New Game Plus x2 (NG+2) in Starfield (PC). On my first run, I completed the "One Step Ahead" Ryujin quest by going to CeltCorp, waiting until the security officer left the office ...[More]


What game is this music from? What game is this music from?

Posted On: September 2, 2023
I was watching some funny Garry's Mod Idiot Box episodes on YouTube. In episode 3 at 5:41 is a scene that has some music being played in the background. What game is from? It sounds so familiar to...[More]


Too easy on normal in Hogwarts Legacy? Too easy on normal in Hogwarts Legacy?

Posted On: April 25, 2023
Hey all just wondering if there any others here who find this game really easy on normal mode? Also be curious to know if the same folks who find this quite easy play games like Dark Souls etc. I v...[More]


Has anyone done an absolutist run? Has anyone done an absolutist run?

Posted On: March 12, 2025
Not killing the mind flayer in the very beginning. Having compassion for it lol. Siding with Minthara. Pick all absolute dialogue options. Let Marcus take Isobel. Get branded. Lol.I was just wondering...[More]