Just entered A3 for the first time. Is this event broken?

[BACK]
Just entered A3 for the first time. Is this event broken?
Posted On: September 29, 2023

I just started Act 3 and found a barn with stuff for the refugees.


I convinced Manip Nestor to let me in the barn and I found a chest full of trapped toys.


I disarmed the traps and this starts a quest about the toys. Immediately after, Manip Nestor runs to me. I explain about the toys and he says "how do I know you're not the one who trapped them?" and goes hostile, together with the other Flaming Fists around.


It feels like I should have gotten a chance to reply, especially because his dialogue is actually cut short, it's like "how do I know y." and we enter combat. This happens on every reload.


Sadly, my only manual save in A3 is right after disarming the toys, so I can't avoid it.


Is this combat normal and unavoidable or is it bugged?


I'm about to enter Baldur's Gate for the very first time and I'd rather not start this experience by slaughtering Flaming Fist.


So some input from people who have been here is appreciated.


If it's normal I'll continue from here, but if it's bugged I'd rather reload my start of A3 autosave and redo everything.


Edit: for people with the same problem who found this thread by googling it, it's confirmed bugged. You're supposed to get a dialogue and not enter combat right away.


Thanks for all the replies. I'll send my save file to Larian through the bug report button.


Question from user GeassedbyLelouch at BaldursGate3 at reddit.


Answer:

So I don’t know whether or not it’s bugged, but you actually did skip ahead a little bit in the quest! This encounter went smoothly for me. There’s a character named Arfur in Rivington who is found outside his home not letting refugees in. If you proceed through this encounter you eventually get to the point where you’re told to investigate the toys in the barn as part of this quest. I was able to answer without the flaming fists going hostile. Then you proceed this quest to baldurs gate.


Answer from user BringinHugsyBack at BaldursGate3 at reddit.



[BACK]
Just entered A3 for the first time. Is this event broken?
Posted On: September 29, 2023

I just started Act 3 and found a barn with stuff for the refugees.


I convinced Manip Nestor to let me in the barn and I found a chest full of trapped toys.


I disarmed the traps and this starts a quest about the toys. Immediately after, Manip Nestor runs to me. I explain about the toys and he says "how do I know you're not the one who trapped them?" and goes hostile, together with the other Flaming Fists around.


It feels like I should have gotten a chance to reply, especially because his dialogue is actually cut short, it's like "how do I know y." and we enter combat. This happens on every reload.


Sadly, my only manual save in A3 is right after disarming the toys, so I can't avoid it.


Is this combat normal and unavoidable or is it bugged?


I'm about to enter Baldur's Gate for the very first time and I'd rather not start this experience by slaughtering Flaming Fist.


So some input from people who have been here is appreciated.


If it's normal I'll continue from here, but if it's bugged I'd rather reload my start of A3 autosave and redo everything.


Edit: for people with the same problem who found this thread by googling it, it's confirmed bugged. You're supposed to get a dialogue and not enter combat right away.


Thanks for all the replies. I'll send my save file to Larian through the bug report button.


Question from user GeassedbyLelouch at BaldursGate3 at reddit.


Answer:

So I don’t know whether or not it’s bugged, but you actually did skip ahead a little bit in the quest! This encounter went smoothly for me. There’s a character named Arfur in Rivington who is found outside his home not letting refugees in. If you proceed through this encounter you eventually get to the point where you’re told to investigate the toys in the barn as part of this quest. I was able to answer without the flaming fists going hostile. Then you proceed this quest to baldurs gate.


Answer from user BringinHugsyBack at BaldursGate3 at reddit.



[BACK]

in Teslagrad Where is this room located on the map? in Teslagrad Where is this room located on the map?

Posted On: April 30, 2023
Recently, I have managed to collect all scrolls and complete the game. But still, there seems to be a room I haven't encountered:. This screenshot can be found at the game's official site (...[More]


What are some tactics to fortify villages and their population against outside attack? What are some tactics to fortify villages and their population against outside attack?

Posted On: January 29, 2023
I recently discovered my homely village has been ransacked by a marauding horde of zombies. They managed to get inside one of my large apartment houses and wiped out all but two (!) of the village pop...[More]


Does the solution to The Shoe Store Thief include the price of the shoes? Does the solution to The Shoe Store Thief include the price of the shoes?

Posted On: April 9, 2023
In Professor Layton and the Diabolical Box, puzzle 20 (The Shoe Store Thief) involves a woman who uses a counterfeit $50 bill to buy a $30 pair of shoes. The puzzle asks how much money the shoe-store ...[More]


Do I sell my legendary Kraken cloak in favour of a superb one? Do I sell my legendary Kraken cloak in favour of a superb one?

Posted On: September 24, 2023
My legendary Kraken cloak provides me with 14 defence while my Superb cloak provides me with 18 defence. Should I sell my legendary gear? I’m pretty new to this game, so don’t really know ...[More]


Craziest take you've heard in the BG3 community? Craziest take you've heard in the BG3 community?

Posted On: June 14, 2025
I just saw someone argue unironically that Wyll is meaner than Astarion and Minthara.Question from user DearPersimmon8155 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.Answer:evil Durge murder hobo is actuelly the mo...[More]


What parts of the ending may change in Zelda Tears of the Kingdom? What parts of the ending may change in Zelda Tears of the Kingdom?

Posted On: June 15, 2023
Just like in BotW, the ending is probably modular, lots of things may or may not be there depending if you did something or not. (Staying vague so if someone that hasn't finished the game opens th...[More]


Why is this Electrolyzer and Hydrogen Generator combo unsustainable? Why is this Electrolyzer and Hydrogen Generator combo unsustainable?

Posted On: April 13, 2024
I have this small Electrolyzer + Hydrogen Generator setup in my base:.The Electrolyzer says it generates 112 g/s of Hydrogen, while the Hydrogen Generator states it needs 100g/s of Hydrogen to functio...[More]


Minecraft doesnt launch with the Ultrasurf proxy? Minecraft doesnt launch with the Ultrasurf proxy?

Posted On: June 7, 2023
I often go to the library to play Minecraft. Since there are a lot of people playing there, enough people put in the wrong credentials such that the library IP is often temporarily banned from the Moj...[More]


Whats the most efficient way to acquire Minecraft Dark Oak Saplings? Whats the most efficient way to acquire Minecraft Dark Oak Saplings?

Posted On: June 5, 2023
I need several stacks of dark oak saplings. By efficient, I'm interested in minimizing game time. I have tons of resources, so throw any resources you can think of at the answer if it will help...[More]


How do I use Artifacts in combat in Neverwinter? How do I use Artifacts in combat in Neverwinter?

Posted On: April 11, 2023
Sorry if this is an obvious question, but I can't find anything online that answers it. You can equip several artifacts on your character sheet. They talk about doing damage to your enemies. How d...[More]