What *exactly* is the action - event that fixes your choice of Grimm Troupe quest?

[BACK]
What *exactly* is the action - event that fixes your choice of Grimm Troupe quest?
Posted On: February 16, 2023

I recently found out that there are 2 options of the final portion of the Grimm Troupe content.


Fight the Nightmare King.


Help Brumm banish the Troupe.


My wife and I have 2 saves, we've both beaten the Troupe Master once.


I have already collected the final set of Grimm Flames, and attempted the NK fight a few times.


My wife hasn't collected any of those final set of flames, though.


But when either of us.


go back to the brazier in the Howling Cliffs, we don't find Brumm :(.


I'm less surprised that I can't. But I expected my wife's game to still allow that path?


Exactly what determines which path you're on, and is it possible to change it at all? (e.g. by editting the save file? I know there are programs that can analyse a save file and tell you what you should look at next, if you're "stuck").


Question from user Brondahl at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

Just verified using save states:.


The exact action that forces you down one road or the other is either killing Nightmare King Grimm (getting defeated in combat and returning to bench doesn't count), or delivering the final blow to the torch in Howling Cliffs (initiating the process, having Brumm damage the torch, and hitting it some yourself doesn't matter).


That means literally you can change your mind up to the very last moment before given ending.


Talking to Brumm in one of small houses in the Distant Village (while having Grimmchild equipped) is necessary to 'unlock' the alternate ending - you won't meet anyone at the torch if you don't talk to Brumm in Distant Village houses, and it's possible after defeating Troupe Master Grimm (accessing the third set of grimmkin) - before that Brumm is in Dirtmouth and talking with him only gives lore. Killing three Nightmare Grimmkin unlocks the 'main' ending, but you can talk to Brumm at any time between finishing the two Grimm fights and delay the decision until the very last moment.


In fact you can lose the fight to Nightmare King Grimm, decide it's too hard for you, find Brumm in the Distant Village and then go destroy the torch. Or you can visit Brumm right after the first Grimm fight, damage the torch (but not destroy it), then kill three Nightmare Grimmkins and Nightmare King Grimm.


In your case, I just suspect neither of you talked to Brumm in the Distant Village - possibly you visited the house without Grimmchild, or just never found it - it's the one left-down from the big one in which the weavers ask you to rest.


Answer from user SF. at gaming.stackexchange.com.



[BACK]
What *exactly* is the action - event that fixes your choice of Grimm Troupe quest?
Posted On: February 16, 2023

I recently found out that there are 2 options of the final portion of the Grimm Troupe content.


Fight the Nightmare King.


Help Brumm banish the Troupe.


My wife and I have 2 saves, we've both beaten the Troupe Master once.


I have already collected the final set of Grimm Flames, and attempted the NK fight a few times.


My wife hasn't collected any of those final set of flames, though.


But when either of us.


go back to the brazier in the Howling Cliffs, we don't find Brumm :(.


I'm less surprised that I can't. But I expected my wife's game to still allow that path?


Exactly what determines which path you're on, and is it possible to change it at all? (e.g. by editting the save file? I know there are programs that can analyse a save file and tell you what you should look at next, if you're "stuck").


Question from user Brondahl at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

Just verified using save states:.


The exact action that forces you down one road or the other is either killing Nightmare King Grimm (getting defeated in combat and returning to bench doesn't count), or delivering the final blow to the torch in Howling Cliffs (initiating the process, having Brumm damage the torch, and hitting it some yourself doesn't matter).


That means literally you can change your mind up to the very last moment before given ending.


Talking to Brumm in one of small houses in the Distant Village (while having Grimmchild equipped) is necessary to 'unlock' the alternate ending - you won't meet anyone at the torch if you don't talk to Brumm in Distant Village houses, and it's possible after defeating Troupe Master Grimm (accessing the third set of grimmkin) - before that Brumm is in Dirtmouth and talking with him only gives lore. Killing three Nightmare Grimmkin unlocks the 'main' ending, but you can talk to Brumm at any time between finishing the two Grimm fights and delay the decision until the very last moment.


In fact you can lose the fight to Nightmare King Grimm, decide it's too hard for you, find Brumm in the Distant Village and then go destroy the torch. Or you can visit Brumm right after the first Grimm fight, damage the torch (but not destroy it), then kill three Nightmare Grimmkins and Nightmare King Grimm.


In your case, I just suspect neither of you talked to Brumm in the Distant Village - possibly you visited the house without Grimmchild, or just never found it - it's the one left-down from the big one in which the weavers ask you to rest.


Answer from user SF. at gaming.stackexchange.com.



[BACK]

Even Astarion thinks the Druids were assholes Even Astarion thinks the Druids were assholes

Posted On: August 24, 2025
Question from user Gay_Banana180 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.Answer:Well if you consider the fact that the Grove was infiltrated by Shadow Druids the lack of hospitality makes sense.Answer from user...[More]


Is Wordle always beatable under optimal play? Is Wordle always beatable under optimal play?

Posted On: June 15, 2023
Is Wordle always beatable under optimal play on easy mode (where you can guess any valid word)? To put the question more formally, does there exist a deterministic computer program that can play Wo...[More]


What are the benefits and disadvantages of the Global Trust and Eden Initiative factions? What are the benefits and disadvantages of the Global Trust and Eden Initiative factions?

Posted On: March 26, 2024
I always play as the Eden Initiative. Am I missing out on anything by not playing Global Trust?Question from user victoriah at gaming.stackexchange.com.Answer:The Global Trust tends to use much more e...[More]


Is there any strategy to 2048 Numberwang? Is there any strategy to 2048 Numberwang?

Posted On: July 22, 2023
I tried out 2048 Numberwang and I can't figure out if there is a strategy to it. Unlike 2048, the numbers keep changing every time you press a key. I just kept randomly pressing the arrow keys unt...[More]


Progression through WoW that avoids spiders Progression through WoW that avoids spiders

Posted On: April 18, 2024
Background: My girlfriend is terrified of spiders. So much so that she cringes and closes her eyes whenever there are spiders on my screen, even if I'm not fighting them. I'm now introducing her to ...[More]


In Beat Saber how do I disable TinyTAN avatars on BTS songs? In Beat Saber how do I disable TinyTAN avatars on BTS songs?

Posted On: March 3, 2023
Sometimes while playing Beat Saber's BTS Music Pack, TinyTAN avatars will appear mid-song and start flying around. The extra distraction makes it difficult to play Expert or Expert+ tracks. Is ...[More]


Not even a scrying eye yelling for help could move her Not even a scrying eye yelling for help could move her

Posted On: January 27, 2026
I legit must of killed like 20 npcs in that tiny room right next to her and she never even budged. The entire time there was a scrying eye alive doing its thing.Question from user RyanCreamer202 at Ba...[More]


Will a Smokepowder Satchel explode if Im lit on fire while carrying it? Will a Smokepowder Satchel explode if Im lit on fire while carrying it?

Posted On: September 5, 2023
I picked up a Smokepowder Satchel that says it explodes when ignited, damaging everything in the vicinity. Some enemy spells can inflict burning. Will a Smokepowder Satchel explode if a character gets...[More]


What games are similar to Hogwarts Legacy? What games are similar to Hogwarts Legacy?

Posted On: April 10, 2023
Looking for suggestions of what to play after I’m done with this game. Are there any games similar that would have you following a story while doing quests or battles? Question from user Harm...[More]


Pokemon GO, What does this symbol mean in the Collector research? Pokemon GO, What does this symbol mean in the Collector research?

Posted On: May 1, 2023
In the temporary research there is a challenge to catch specific pokemon. Some are normal, some are event, but there is one that I'm not sure what it means. What does this symbol mean? Qu...[More]