Why is this Electrolyzer and Hydrogen Generator combo unsustainable?

[BACK]
Why is this Electrolyzer and Hydrogen Generator combo unsustainable?
Posted On: April 13, 2024

I have this small Electrolyzer + Hydrogen Generator setup in my base:.


The Electrolyzer says it generates 112 g/s of Hydrogen, while the Hydrogen Generator states it needs 100g/s of Hydrogen to function and produce 800W of power.


The Hydrolyzer also generates 888g/s of Oxygen, which amounts to 1000g/s of total gas. The Pumps can pump 500g/s of gases each and the Gas Filter is able to handle the full 1000g/s on its own.


Power-wise it is a closed system, and the pumps and filter draw 720W total. So the whole system should have a positive net of 80W.


Even if this all checks out and in theory this should be auto-sustained, in practice the system can't run on his own without the dupes filling the connected battery manually at least once a day.


Am I missing something here? Thanks in advance!.


Question from user GigiSan at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

The gas filter requires 120W per packet of gas that passes through. If a packet of 1000g goes through, it requires 120W. If a packet of 4g goes through, it will still require 120W.


As the hydrogen packets that you pump out are very tiny the process of filtering wastes a lot of power, this causes this setup to not be sustainable.


You need to either save power by using a cheaper solution for filtering gases, or use one of the well-tried Self-Powering Oxygen Machine setups.


Answer from user Simon Forsberg at gaming.stackexchange.com.


[BACK]
Why is this Electrolyzer and Hydrogen Generator combo unsustainable?
Posted On: April 13, 2024

I have this small Electrolyzer + Hydrogen Generator setup in my base:.


The Electrolyzer says it generates 112 g/s of Hydrogen, while the Hydrogen Generator states it needs 100g/s of Hydrogen to function and produce 800W of power.


The Hydrolyzer also generates 888g/s of Oxygen, which amounts to 1000g/s of total gas. The Pumps can pump 500g/s of gases each and the Gas Filter is able to handle the full 1000g/s on its own.


Power-wise it is a closed system, and the pumps and filter draw 720W total. So the whole system should have a positive net of 80W.


Even if this all checks out and in theory this should be auto-sustained, in practice the system can't run on his own without the dupes filling the connected battery manually at least once a day.


Am I missing something here? Thanks in advance!.


Question from user GigiSan at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

The gas filter requires 120W per packet of gas that passes through. If a packet of 1000g goes through, it requires 120W. If a packet of 4g goes through, it will still require 120W.


As the hydrogen packets that you pump out are very tiny the process of filtering wastes a lot of power, this causes this setup to not be sustainable.


You need to either save power by using a cheaper solution for filtering gases, or use one of the well-tried Self-Powering Oxygen Machine setups.


Answer from user Simon Forsberg at gaming.stackexchange.com.


[BACK]

In Terraria, do some items make the Blood Moon event more common? In Terraria, do some items make the Blood Moon event more common?

Posted On: March 14, 2023
I'm playing in a new 1.2 world, and the Blood Moon rises nearly every night! My character is currently weak enough that I'm having a tough time staying alive, and it's getting to be frustr...[More]


In Minecraft, what to do with all these Iron ingots? In Minecraft, what to do with all these Iron ingots?

Posted On: February 15, 2023
So I have about 10 iron ingots, but not sure what to start using them for first. Which is the more important thing to invest my ingots? I know armor swords and tools are important, but what is my prio...[More]


How do I stop a mother from breastfeeding? How do I stop a mother from breastfeeding?

Posted On: March 13, 2024
My colony recently welcomed a dirtmole hybrid into its community. The lil' tyke has -4 metabolism, which means a x200% food requirement, and had not reached one quadrum in age before coming down with ...[More]


How do I pass the level 7 will find forward puzzle? How do I pass the level 7 will find forward puzzle?

Posted On: June 12, 2023
The objective is to delete all the red outlined characters. . It allows only 12 key presses and you enter from the bridge above (on either n, d or the space after "find)". Leaving the puz...[More]


How do I find the missing Gold Skulltulas? How do I find the missing Gold Skulltulas?

Posted On: August 5, 2023
I've almost completely finished Ocarina of Time now, and I'd like to get 100% completion just for the fun of it. The big problem is the Gold Skulltulas. I've heard there's some sort...[More]


Wyll got one shotted before his first turn ever Wyll got one shotted before his first turn ever

Posted On: March 27, 2025
What a great way to start my first tactician run. Wyll got critted by a goblin before his first turn.Question from user PapaPepper1999 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.Answer:Provoke the blade, and suffe...[More]


What are the upgrade paths for the academy? What are the upgrade paths for the academy?

Posted On: January 24, 2023
The academy only shows what unit type it upgrades to for existing units already in the army, and only if you've already unlocked the correct race and level upgrades. Can anyone provide or link to a di...[More]


Dark Souls 3, How do I kill the Abyss Watchers? Dark Souls 3, How do I kill the Abyss Watchers?

Posted On: May 21, 2023
I have been trying so hard for a week and I can't figure out how to kill these guys. I can finish off the first phase but no matter how hard I try, I can't kill the fire dude! Does anyone k...[More]


Hearthstone keeps crashing on Lutris on Ubuntu Hearthstone keeps crashing on Lutris on Ubuntu

Posted On: June 5, 2023
I just installed Lutris to play Hearthstone on Ubuntu. Battle.net launcher and the game launches, the bar door screen, Hearthstone text, settings and social buttons appear then the game shuts down. . ...[More]


Sheathe wand Sheathe wand

Posted On: September 15, 2023
If there are going to be any dlc or a second game , i beg you game developers to make a button to sheathe the wand or to have it in your hand until you manually put it back . It is a nice little detai...[More]