Why is this Electrolyzer and Hydrogen Generator combo unsustainable?

[BACK]
Why is this Electrolyzer and Hydrogen Generator combo unsustainable?
Posted On: April 13, 2024

I have this small Electrolyzer + Hydrogen Generator setup in my base:.


The Electrolyzer says it generates 112 g/s of Hydrogen, while the Hydrogen Generator states it needs 100g/s of Hydrogen to function and produce 800W of power.


The Hydrolyzer also generates 888g/s of Oxygen, which amounts to 1000g/s of total gas. The Pumps can pump 500g/s of gases each and the Gas Filter is able to handle the full 1000g/s on its own.


Power-wise it is a closed system, and the pumps and filter draw 720W total. So the whole system should have a positive net of 80W.


Even if this all checks out and in theory this should be auto-sustained, in practice the system can't run on his own without the dupes filling the connected battery manually at least once a day.


Am I missing something here? Thanks in advance!.


Question from user GigiSan at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

The gas filter requires 120W per packet of gas that passes through. If a packet of 1000g goes through, it requires 120W. If a packet of 4g goes through, it will still require 120W.


As the hydrogen packets that you pump out are very tiny the process of filtering wastes a lot of power, this causes this setup to not be sustainable.


You need to either save power by using a cheaper solution for filtering gases, or use one of the well-tried Self-Powering Oxygen Machine setups.


Answer from user Simon Forsberg at gaming.stackexchange.com.


[BACK]
Why is this Electrolyzer and Hydrogen Generator combo unsustainable?
Posted On: April 13, 2024

I have this small Electrolyzer + Hydrogen Generator setup in my base:.


The Electrolyzer says it generates 112 g/s of Hydrogen, while the Hydrogen Generator states it needs 100g/s of Hydrogen to function and produce 800W of power.


The Hydrolyzer also generates 888g/s of Oxygen, which amounts to 1000g/s of total gas. The Pumps can pump 500g/s of gases each and the Gas Filter is able to handle the full 1000g/s on its own.


Power-wise it is a closed system, and the pumps and filter draw 720W total. So the whole system should have a positive net of 80W.


Even if this all checks out and in theory this should be auto-sustained, in practice the system can't run on his own without the dupes filling the connected battery manually at least once a day.


Am I missing something here? Thanks in advance!.


Question from user GigiSan at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

The gas filter requires 120W per packet of gas that passes through. If a packet of 1000g goes through, it requires 120W. If a packet of 4g goes through, it will still require 120W.


As the hydrogen packets that you pump out are very tiny the process of filtering wastes a lot of power, this causes this setup to not be sustainable.


You need to either save power by using a cheaper solution for filtering gases, or use one of the well-tried Self-Powering Oxygen Machine setups.


Answer from user Simon Forsberg at gaming.stackexchange.com.


[BACK]

Any useful strategies for finding a Nether Fortress in Minecraft? Any useful strategies for finding a Nether Fortress in Minecraft?

Posted On: June 20, 2023
Anyone have useful strategies for finding a Nether Fortress in Minecraft's Nether? I got into the nether and wandered around for quite a while, but didn't find anything. I'm not sure if...[More]


Elder Scrolls V: Is there a reliable, continuous source for dragon locations? Elder Scrolls V: Is there a reliable, continuous source for dragon locations?

Posted On: August 26, 2023
I'm trying to gather bones and scales to make armor for one character, and I've come to realize that there's never really any dragons around when you want them to be. Is there a reliabl...[More]


Whats the quickest way to get all of the achievements in StarCraft 2? Whats the quickest way to get all of the achievements in StarCraft 2?

Posted On: February 24, 2023
As the title says, are there any shortcuts to getting all of the achievements in the game (preferably without cheesing through games, etc.)? Question from user happy_soil at gaming.stackexchange.co...[More]


2 levels of fighter in Karlach is a must. Am I wrong? 2 levels of fighter in Karlach is a must. Am I wrong?

Posted On: November 7, 2023
She cannot compete with Laezel without Action Surge. I want to use her more but straight Barbarian is suboptimal for my one frontline melee spot. Question from user mrmrmrj at BaldursGate3 at reddi...[More]


Does boss difficulty change depending on the floor? Does boss difficulty change depending on the floor?

Posted On: February 27, 2024
In Splatoon 3 Side Order, because of the randomization of the tower, there are three bosses that can be fought on either floor 10 or 20 (Asynchronous Rondo, Pinging Marciale, and Parallel Canon).Does ...[More]


What is a Turtle Goal in Rocket League? What is a Turtle Goal in Rocket League?

Posted On: May 7, 2023
While playing ranked doubles, I received 20 points for a turtle goal. . What is a turtle goal? Question from user HazyKingdom at gaming.stackexchange.com. Answer: When you score a goal by ...[More]


Waukeen's rest cannot be saved Waukeen's rest cannot be saved

Posted On: July 12, 2025
Hey all. I've just encountered Waukeen's Rest in my save; where I came through the mountain pass, beat Kith'rak Voss and his fellow githyanki soldiers and finally came upon the burning building. IMMED...[More]


Is the druid Tav's animal form different from others druids? Is the druid Tav's animal form different from others druids?

Posted On: November 12, 2023
I started playing coop with a friend and he was amazed asking me why my bear form was white, because he already finished the game and was telling me that he remembers that druids transformed into brow...[More]


Is it possible to hold my wand in my left hand in Hogwarts Legacy? Is it possible to hold my wand in my left hand in Hogwarts Legacy?

Posted On: July 19, 2023
By default, my character is right handed and holds the wand in his right hand. Is there a way I can change my character to be left handed and hold the wand in my left hand? Question from user Sh...[More]


What game is this character in the Pixels movie from? What game is this character in the Pixels movie from?

Posted On: April 19, 2024
What is this arcade character from? (this is from the Pixels movie).Question from user Questwalker at gaming.stackexchange.com.Answer:This is one of the red-winged moth-looking enemies from Galaga.Scr...[More]