Does harming a companion indirectly with Warding Bond affect their approval?

[BACK]
Does harming a companion indirectly with Warding Bond affect their approval?
Posted On: March 14, 2024

If one of my companions casts.


Warding Bond.


on my main character, and therefore takes damage whenever "I" do, does.


harming them in that way cause their approval to decrease?


I would think not, since the caster should understand how their own.


spell works, but Shadowheart often (maybe half the time?) complains.


about the redirected damage as if it was intentional, asking for.


example, "Did you do that on purpose?!".


Example screenshot of the combat log (Tav is my main character):.


Is her approval dropping because of that?


I can't tell from the in-game approval display because it.


is just a meter with no number, making it very hard to notice small.


changes.


I've done some searching but it's been difficult to avoid spoilers. For.


example, I haven't read the entire Warding Bond article linked above.


because it quickly descends into "OP strats", etc., which I don't want.


to see.


Question from user Scott McPeak at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

After some experimentation, I conclude that no, harming companions.


indirectly with Warding Bond does not affect their approval. They.


complain, but the complaints are inconsequential.


First, I'll note that the approval is available as a number, just in a.


different part of the UI than where I was looking. Specifically, in the.


"details" tab, it's near the bottom:.


Checking this number after each action, I discovered:.


Direct damage does affect approval. If my main character hits.


Shadowheart with three melee attacks (even fists), she will lower her.


approval by 10, and a message "Shadowheart disapproves" appears.


briefly in the center of the screen (not in the corner like for.


dialogue). Missed attacks have no effect on approval.


Complaint dialogue lines ("Watch it, oaf!") have no connection to.


approval. Any time she takes damage or is attacked (even on a miss).


and attributes the source of damage to my character, she has about a.


25% chance to speak a complaint line. (I didn't test with other.


companions doing damage.).


Damaging her indirectly with Warding Bond never affects approval,.


regardless of whether the damage is environmental or from an attack, and.


regardless of whether the damage incapacitates her.


Answer from user Scott McPeak at gaming.stackexchange.com.


[BACK]
Does harming a companion indirectly with Warding Bond affect their approval?
Posted On: March 14, 2024

If one of my companions casts.


Warding Bond.


on my main character, and therefore takes damage whenever "I" do, does.


harming them in that way cause their approval to decrease?


I would think not, since the caster should understand how their own.


spell works, but Shadowheart often (maybe half the time?) complains.


about the redirected damage as if it was intentional, asking for.


example, "Did you do that on purpose?!".


Example screenshot of the combat log (Tav is my main character):.


Is her approval dropping because of that?


I can't tell from the in-game approval display because it.


is just a meter with no number, making it very hard to notice small.


changes.


I've done some searching but it's been difficult to avoid spoilers. For.


example, I haven't read the entire Warding Bond article linked above.


because it quickly descends into "OP strats", etc., which I don't want.


to see.


Question from user Scott McPeak at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

After some experimentation, I conclude that no, harming companions.


indirectly with Warding Bond does not affect their approval. They.


complain, but the complaints are inconsequential.


First, I'll note that the approval is available as a number, just in a.


different part of the UI than where I was looking. Specifically, in the.


"details" tab, it's near the bottom:.


Checking this number after each action, I discovered:.


Direct damage does affect approval. If my main character hits.


Shadowheart with three melee attacks (even fists), she will lower her.


approval by 10, and a message "Shadowheart disapproves" appears.


briefly in the center of the screen (not in the corner like for.


dialogue). Missed attacks have no effect on approval.


Complaint dialogue lines ("Watch it, oaf!") have no connection to.


approval. Any time she takes damage or is attacked (even on a miss).


and attributes the source of damage to my character, she has about a.


25% chance to speak a complaint line. (I didn't test with other.


companions doing damage.).


Damaging her indirectly with Warding Bond never affects approval,.


regardless of whether the damage is environmental or from an attack, and.


regardless of whether the damage incapacitates her.


Answer from user Scott McPeak at gaming.stackexchange.com.


[BACK]

How can I tell if a corpse is safe to eat? How can I tell if a corpse is safe to eat?

Posted On: July 9, 2020
I am a human wizard, and I just killed a monster, leaving a corpse on the ground. How do I tell whether it is safe to eat the corpse? I left the monster unspecified because I am interested in "...[More]


In EVE, What happens to skills in the training queue when an account reverts to alpha clone status? In EVE, What happens to skills in the training queue when an account reverts to alpha clone status?

Posted On: March 9, 2023
I have a bunch of skills queued to train, which includes advanced skills that an Alpha clone cannot train and several skills that are scheduled to start several days out. Since these two conditions ar...[More]


Does Echo Form stack with itself? Does Echo Form stack with itself?

Posted On: January 4, 2024
The description for the Power card Echo Form states. The first card you play each turn is played twice. What happens if you play Echo Form multiple times in a battle? Does the first card played ...[More]


Is BG3 worth it for someone who doesn't like the setting? Is BG3 worth it for someone who doesn't like the setting?

Posted On: December 15, 2025
Hi, I'm a long time D&D fan, although most of my experience comes from the older editions (B/X edition and AD&D 1e are my faves), not much 5e experience (tried to run 5e campaigns on two separate occa...[More]


How can I get more coal? How can I get more coal?

Posted On: January 11, 2023
I'm running out of fuel and need some coal. I have no trees and I don't want to waste the little wood I have left. How can I find more?Question from user Young Guilo at gaming.stackexchange.com.Answer...[More]


Can someone tell me what is wrong with my game in Hogwarts Legacy? Can someone tell me what is wrong with my game in Hogwarts Legacy?

Posted On: May 21, 2023
I’ve tried most of the settings and the game is still very laggy when trying to talk or do anything. . Also nightmare fuel graphics. AlL NPC/ characters look like this. Question from user ...[More]


The last thing I expected from this game. The last thing I expected from this game.

Posted On: September 16, 2023
I'm on my first play through as a Hufflepuff witch, and I have to say I'm bowled over by the outfits and how good they look. The costume design team have done such a good job. My wardrobe is s...[More]


Uhh, I got drunk and trashed a temple. How do I pick up the mess? Uhh, I got drunk and trashed a temple. How do I pick up the mess?

Posted On: December 20, 2018
After getting shouted at rather intensely by four old guys on the top of a "7000 steps" tall mountain, I decided it was time to go home to Whiterun and have a couple cups of mead. . Fortu...[More]


Can I progress without doing isobel’s fight encounter? Can I progress without doing isobel’s fight encounter?

Posted On: November 25, 2023
I think I’ve reloaded my save 6 or 7 times trying to save this & I can’t for the life of me make it happen. I think the closest I’ve gotten has been getting Marcus down to like 3...[More]


Why is this Electrolyzer and Hydrogen Generator combo unsustainable? Why is this Electrolyzer and Hydrogen Generator combo unsustainable?

Posted On: April 13, 2024
I have this small Electrolyzer + Hydrogen Generator setup in my base:.The Electrolyzer says it generates 112 g/s of Hydrogen, while the Hydrogen Generator states it needs 100g/s of Hydrogen to functio...[More]