Friends cant connect to my server with external IP

[BACK]
Friends cant connect to my server with external IP
Posted On: February 9, 2023

Year after year I have been the one to host a minecraft server for a few weeks when the new minecraft update comes so me and my buddies can have some nostalgia.


Every year I set up the server. In my router settings I set the port and double check the if the server's internal ip is still good. and done. Then I give my friends my external ip. And everything works fine.


But this year I can't figure out why. None of them can join. Everything is the same. The router and it's settings, the pc I run the server on.


I'm the only one who can join the server and only with it's internal IP. But not with external one.


I just can't figure it out. I looked around for posts on the subject but did not manage the solve the problem.


What I have tried so far:.


Disabling the Firewall.


Resetting the Router.


Checking if the port forwarded internal ip is the right one.


Please help!.


Question from user John at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

You may have been put behind CG-NAT (Carrier Grade NAT) wich would explain your problem very well. The short answer for why is that we are running out of IPv4 addresses. If you want the long answer for why, then you can read more about it here:.


https://www.a10networks.com/glossary/what-is-carrier-grade-nat-cgn-cgnat/.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrier-grade_NAT.


You should be able to test this by having your friends connect to you with your IPv6 address instead, if it is activated. If that works, then you're surely behind CG-NAT. Most ISP's should have IPv6 activated by now. Also, if you have a old router, IPv6 might not be activated by default or even worse, not be supported at all.


If above works, then you don't really need to do anything as long as you play modern games that support IPv6.


But contact your ISP and ask them if they have done something, if you are behind CG-NAT.


If it turns out that this is the case, then you can ask them for a public IPv4 address wich is the "normal" way. Some ISP's let you change back for free while some charge you for it. Some ISP's don't even have that service.


Another solution is to set up a virtual LAN. There are a couple of different softwares that can be used for this. GameRanger is a popular one. Hamachi used to be very popular, but don't seem to be so anymore.


Answer from user ELF at gaming.stackexchange.com.



[BACK]
Friends cant connect to my server with external IP
Posted On: February 9, 2023

Year after year I have been the one to host a minecraft server for a few weeks when the new minecraft update comes so me and my buddies can have some nostalgia.


Every year I set up the server. In my router settings I set the port and double check the if the server's internal ip is still good. and done. Then I give my friends my external ip. And everything works fine.


But this year I can't figure out why. None of them can join. Everything is the same. The router and it's settings, the pc I run the server on.


I'm the only one who can join the server and only with it's internal IP. But not with external one.


I just can't figure it out. I looked around for posts on the subject but did not manage the solve the problem.


What I have tried so far:.


Disabling the Firewall.


Resetting the Router.


Checking if the port forwarded internal ip is the right one.


Please help!.


Question from user John at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

You may have been put behind CG-NAT (Carrier Grade NAT) wich would explain your problem very well. The short answer for why is that we are running out of IPv4 addresses. If you want the long answer for why, then you can read more about it here:.


https://www.a10networks.com/glossary/what-is-carrier-grade-nat-cgn-cgnat/.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrier-grade_NAT.


You should be able to test this by having your friends connect to you with your IPv6 address instead, if it is activated. If that works, then you're surely behind CG-NAT. Most ISP's should have IPv6 activated by now. Also, if you have a old router, IPv6 might not be activated by default or even worse, not be supported at all.


If above works, then you don't really need to do anything as long as you play modern games that support IPv6.


But contact your ISP and ask them if they have done something, if you are behind CG-NAT.


If it turns out that this is the case, then you can ask them for a public IPv4 address wich is the "normal" way. Some ISP's let you change back for free while some charge you for it. Some ISP's don't even have that service.


Another solution is to set up a virtual LAN. There are a couple of different softwares that can be used for this. GameRanger is a popular one. Hamachi used to be very popular, but don't seem to be so anymore.


Answer from user ELF at gaming.stackexchange.com.



[BACK]

Infuriating plot point Infuriating plot point

Posted On: October 2, 2023
Is anyone else infuriated by the way the tadpoles are handled? We're told from the outset that these things are bad, like as bad as you can get. Literally no reason you would want them at all, but...[More]


What do the numbers next to the achievements mean in Overwatch? What do the numbers next to the achievements mean in Overwatch?

Posted On: May 18, 2023
Next to each achievement in Overwatch there's a little number in a circle, what does that mean? Question from user Wrigglenite at gaming.stackexchange.com. Answer: The number signifies th...[More]


How do Steam Workshop mods and Nexus mods interact? How do Steam Workshop mods and Nexus mods interact?

Posted On: February 9, 2023
All of my mods so far are on the Steam Workshop, but there are a few on Nexus that look to be quite useful. My question before I dive in is are there any potential problems that I need to be aware of...[More]


How to farm large amount of studs in Lego Star Wars The Force Awakens How to farm large amount of studs in Lego Star Wars The Force Awakens

Posted On: March 25, 2023
I have been playing through Lego Star Wars: The Force Awakens. Once you get to the end of the game most of the characters are unlocked but you need to actually "buy" them in order to use ...[More]


Do Squirrel Bits Actually Come From Squirrels in Fallout 4? Do Squirrel Bits Actually Come From Squirrels in Fallout 4?

Posted On: March 12, 2023
There are two main things that led me to this question: 1) I've never seen a squirrel in the Commonwealth, and 2) I learned that some meat sources are intentionally mislabeled (see Longneck Lukows...[More]


Do gamepads always deteriorate from extended disuse and is there anything to be done about it? Do gamepads always deteriorate from extended disuse and is there anything to be done about it?

Posted On: May 15, 2023
I've owned two USB gamepads for PC now. The first was some noname pad I got really cheap in a supermarket. The second was (and is) Logitech Rumblepad 2. In both cases I've had the same problem...[More]


How do I get Avada kedavra in Hogwarts Legacy? How do I get Avada kedavra in Hogwarts Legacy?

Posted On: March 17, 2023
So you're telling me the last spell I needed for 100 is no longer unlockable because I thought seb killing his uncle was wrong?! Like every other curse tells you if you do this you won't get i...[More]


Consequences of poor performance early in the campaign Consequences of poor performance early in the campaign

Posted On: December 4, 2023
In vanilla DoW2's campaign, does wasting time before the Tyranids show up have any consequences? A friend and I have been playing vanilla DoW 2's coop campaign mode. However, we screwed up ...[More]


Is there a way to increase the number of potions I can carry in Final Fantasy 16? Is there a way to increase the number of potions I can carry in Final Fantasy 16?

Posted On: July 25, 2023
I'm still in the early parts of Final Fantasy 16, and Clive can only carry 4 potions and 3 high potions. During certain boss fights, I found myself using them all early on in the fights and not ha...[More]


Slay The Spire: Does defeating minions reward extra gold? Slay The Spire: Does defeating minions reward extra gold?

Posted On: January 15, 2024
When fighting an Elite Enemy, they can sometimes summon minions to assist them in the fight. Defeating the Elite causes any surviving minions to run away. Will defeating the minions before defeating t...[More]