New player here - does shadowheart suck early game?

[BACK]
New player here - does shadowheart suck early game?
Posted On: November 15, 2024

I’m playing on Tactician. I thought healing would be nice to have but because it’s limited by having to long rest (and I’m trying to save camp supplies) I am very conservative with it. I feel like doing damage would just be better, but she has a fireball cantrip with 10 INT lmao or the radiance one that is a 1d8…. .


She feels very underwhelming and I wonder if I’m better off shelving her until later? I am a level 4 Warlock, with Laezel, Karlach, and I think I’m gonna sub Asterion in for more damage .


Edit: too many comments to reply to but just want to say thank you, I was indeed thinking of her in a very limited capacity and appreciate the insight of getting more use out of her.


Question from user IWillFlakeOnOurPlans at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


Answer:

Think of a DND cleric as a swiss army knife. They might not have the best tools in any single capacity outside of healing, but they can always contribute to any situation. A trap that many people fall into, that you seem to be as well, is that healing is what theyre meant to do as spell casters. Spell based healing should be more of a last option. .


If you look at her level 1 spell list, her best healing spell is 1d8+Wis bonus, or roughly 3-11 healing. Thats nice, but for the same spell slot she could also cast Inflict Wounds, which is 3-30 damage, Guiding Bolt, which deals 4-24 damage and grants Advantage, making the next attack from anyone on that target easier to hit. Both are going to be better than healing unless that character absolutely needs healing now. You could also cast Command to make an enemy waste a turn, saving as much damage as you could heal or more, Bless to make your companions attacks more accurate and save them from status effects by enhancing their saving throws, or Bane to cripple an enemy. All of those options are more impactful than her healing until characters are in immediate danger of being downed.


Answer from user actiongeorge at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


[BACK]
New player here - does shadowheart suck early game?
Posted On: November 15, 2024

I’m playing on Tactician. I thought healing would be nice to have but because it’s limited by having to long rest (and I’m trying to save camp supplies) I am very conservative with it. I feel like doing damage would just be better, but she has a fireball cantrip with 10 INT lmao or the radiance one that is a 1d8…. .


She feels very underwhelming and I wonder if I’m better off shelving her until later? I am a level 4 Warlock, with Laezel, Karlach, and I think I’m gonna sub Asterion in for more damage .


Edit: too many comments to reply to but just want to say thank you, I was indeed thinking of her in a very limited capacity and appreciate the insight of getting more use out of her.


Question from user IWillFlakeOnOurPlans at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


Answer:

Think of a DND cleric as a swiss army knife. They might not have the best tools in any single capacity outside of healing, but they can always contribute to any situation. A trap that many people fall into, that you seem to be as well, is that healing is what theyre meant to do as spell casters. Spell based healing should be more of a last option. .


If you look at her level 1 spell list, her best healing spell is 1d8+Wis bonus, or roughly 3-11 healing. Thats nice, but for the same spell slot she could also cast Inflict Wounds, which is 3-30 damage, Guiding Bolt, which deals 4-24 damage and grants Advantage, making the next attack from anyone on that target easier to hit. Both are going to be better than healing unless that character absolutely needs healing now. You could also cast Command to make an enemy waste a turn, saving as much damage as you could heal or more, Bless to make your companions attacks more accurate and save them from status effects by enhancing their saving throws, or Bane to cripple an enemy. All of those options are more impactful than her healing until characters are in immediate danger of being downed.


Answer from user actiongeorge at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


[BACK]

Did any of Metagaming Concepts board games make it to the PC? Did any of Metagaming Concepts board games make it to the PC?

Posted On: June 11, 2023
I loved Metagaming Concepts' board games like Ogre and WarpWar and always thought that they could have been made into PC games. Did any of Metagaming Concepts' board games make it to the PC...[More]


Is there a limit to common boons, and what happens if you reach it? Is there a limit to common boons, and what happens if you reach it?

Posted On: March 27, 2024
In Hades, if you look at the 'normal' boons list, there seems to be 22 slots (4 rows that alternate 5 or 6 slots).Is that 22 limit a hard limit, and if you reach for your 23rd boon, what happens?Quest...[More]


In Pokemon Go does the Vivilion postcard pinning overflow to the next medal? In Pokemon Go does the Vivilion postcard pinning overflow to the next medal?

Posted On: March 3, 2023
If I have a Vivilion medal at 12 out of 15 and then pins 5 postcards for that model, would the medal be completed and the left over of 2 be brought over to the next medal? Or would the new medal st...[More]


How to mark items as junk in The Outer Worlds? How to mark items as junk in The Outer Worlds?

Posted On: May 2, 2023
Items you've marked as Junk can be sold in bulk. Okay, so how do I mark items as junk? There is no UI in the game or anything else, just a tip that suggests that you can mark items as junk. ...[More]


Does leaving the car on use up fuel? Does leaving the car on use up fuel?

Posted On: March 3, 2024
In Pacific Drive, when I put the car in park I can exit the car without turning off the engine. Does leaving the engine turned on use up fuel if the car isn't moving?Question from user Stevoisiak at g...[More]


Hint needed on last Spirit of Arkham (Arkham Asylum) Hint needed on last Spirit of Arkham (Arkham Asylum)

Posted On: January 31, 2023
I'm trying to find the last Spirit of Arkham in Batman, Arkham Asylum, but I am totally stumped. I have otherwise completed the game 100% (including the challenges) and this seems to be the last thing...[More]


About the paladin characters... About the paladin characters...

Posted On: January 6, 2026
Thinking about the paladins I've seen in this game, Zevlor, Minthara, the false Tyr paladin I forgot the name of, Ketheric Thorm.are ANY of them good aligned? When I think paladin, I think of an armor...[More]


Why does the Pokémon count show one more than the actual Pokémon I have? Why does the Pokémon count show one more than the actual Pokémon I have?

Posted On: June 17, 2023
I have 11 Pokémon, none duplicate. But the count at the top shows 12. Is this a bug, or does it count the Pokémon in the egg, too? Question from user Shaunak D at stackexchange. ...[More]


Where is the best place to get the Hot PotatOwned achievement in HL2: EP2? Where is the best place to get the Hot PotatOwned achievement in HL2: EP2?

Posted On: December 30, 2023
I'm using a PC, so I can't just get the achievement in HL2 or HL2: EP1. I would like to know, where the best place is to get the achievement. Question from user Tyilo at stackexchange. ...[More]


Can a missed shot in Xcom2 still execute? Can a missed shot in Xcom2 still execute?

Posted On: July 5, 2023
If you have a weapon which has both a Repeater and a Stock attached to it. Is there any chance that a missed shot will trigger the Repeater?. My assumption is that it will not as the actual shot di...[More]