New player here - does shadowheart suck early game?

[BACK]
New player here - does shadowheart suck early game?
Posted On: November 15, 2024

I’m playing on Tactician. I thought healing would be nice to have but because it’s limited by having to long rest (and I’m trying to save camp supplies) I am very conservative with it. I feel like doing damage would just be better, but she has a fireball cantrip with 10 INT lmao or the radiance one that is a 1d8…. .


She feels very underwhelming and I wonder if I’m better off shelving her until later? I am a level 4 Warlock, with Laezel, Karlach, and I think I’m gonna sub Asterion in for more damage .


Edit: too many comments to reply to but just want to say thank you, I was indeed thinking of her in a very limited capacity and appreciate the insight of getting more use out of her.


Question from user IWillFlakeOnOurPlans at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


Answer:

Think of a DND cleric as a swiss army knife. They might not have the best tools in any single capacity outside of healing, but they can always contribute to any situation. A trap that many people fall into, that you seem to be as well, is that healing is what theyre meant to do as spell casters. Spell based healing should be more of a last option. .


If you look at her level 1 spell list, her best healing spell is 1d8+Wis bonus, or roughly 3-11 healing. Thats nice, but for the same spell slot she could also cast Inflict Wounds, which is 3-30 damage, Guiding Bolt, which deals 4-24 damage and grants Advantage, making the next attack from anyone on that target easier to hit. Both are going to be better than healing unless that character absolutely needs healing now. You could also cast Command to make an enemy waste a turn, saving as much damage as you could heal or more, Bless to make your companions attacks more accurate and save them from status effects by enhancing their saving throws, or Bane to cripple an enemy. All of those options are more impactful than her healing until characters are in immediate danger of being downed.


Answer from user actiongeorge at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


[BACK]
New player here - does shadowheart suck early game?
Posted On: November 15, 2024

I’m playing on Tactician. I thought healing would be nice to have but because it’s limited by having to long rest (and I’m trying to save camp supplies) I am very conservative with it. I feel like doing damage would just be better, but she has a fireball cantrip with 10 INT lmao or the radiance one that is a 1d8…. .


She feels very underwhelming and I wonder if I’m better off shelving her until later? I am a level 4 Warlock, with Laezel, Karlach, and I think I’m gonna sub Asterion in for more damage .


Edit: too many comments to reply to but just want to say thank you, I was indeed thinking of her in a very limited capacity and appreciate the insight of getting more use out of her.


Question from user IWillFlakeOnOurPlans at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


Answer:

Think of a DND cleric as a swiss army knife. They might not have the best tools in any single capacity outside of healing, but they can always contribute to any situation. A trap that many people fall into, that you seem to be as well, is that healing is what theyre meant to do as spell casters. Spell based healing should be more of a last option. .


If you look at her level 1 spell list, her best healing spell is 1d8+Wis bonus, or roughly 3-11 healing. Thats nice, but for the same spell slot she could also cast Inflict Wounds, which is 3-30 damage, Guiding Bolt, which deals 4-24 damage and grants Advantage, making the next attack from anyone on that target easier to hit. Both are going to be better than healing unless that character absolutely needs healing now. You could also cast Command to make an enemy waste a turn, saving as much damage as you could heal or more, Bless to make your companions attacks more accurate and save them from status effects by enhancing their saving throws, or Bane to cripple an enemy. All of those options are more impactful than her healing until characters are in immediate danger of being downed.


Answer from user actiongeorge at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.


[BACK]

Can I turn off this Necromancer visual effect? Can I turn off this Necromancer visual effect?

Posted On: June 16, 2023
I was in a team with a Necromancer and one the skills was to create a patch of black smoke. However this skill seems to just obscure everything! My character, my loot, enemies and even chests. This...[More]


Dungeons and Dragons Online, Good for Groups? Dungeons and Dragons Online, Good for Groups?

Posted On: June 11, 2023
I see that Dungeons and Dragons Online is now free to play. How is that game structured?. Do you create parties and travel?. Or is it more free world-ish?. I ask because I am looking for g...[More]


Floo Flames in Hogwarts Legacy Floo Flames in Hogwarts Legacy

Posted On: March 24, 2023
LoL anybody else in here make it a point to visit every last floo flame on the map shortly after u got ur broom? I'm like 16 hours into the game and barely %25 done with the game  Question...[More]


How do you hire a Hacker in Game Dev Story? How do you hire a Hacker in Game Dev Story?

Posted On: April 13, 2024
I'm on my second playthrough of Game Dev Story, choosing the Hire option at least twice per game year and varying between "Word of Mouth", "Magazine Ad", and "Online Ad" — never seen a Hacker availa...[More]


Which house do you find to be the coziest? Which house do you find to be the coziest?

Posted On: September 19, 2023
I have done a play through as 3 of the four houses (Ravenclaw, Slytherin, and Gryffindor). I find that Gryffindor is more cozy than the other two. Might just be because the colors are warmer. Hufflepu...[More]


Why don't I love my Dragonborn as I did my Argonians? Why don't I love my Dragonborn as I did my Argonians?

Posted On: March 22, 2026
I can't pinpoint what it is, but I had a fantastic time playing lizard people in Morrowind, Oblivion and Skyrim. It felt different, fun and interesting. The racial traits didn't matter to me - I just ...[More]


Dead or Alive: Dimensions Control Mechanism Dead or Alive: Dimensions Control Mechanism

Posted On: March 24, 2023
In the recently released title for the Nintendo 3DS, some of the video previews seem to suggest that the characters are controlled by "selecting" combinations on the touch screen, rather tha...[More]


If I put a key in a capsule, can I get another in Ingress? If I put a key in a capsule, can I get another in Ingress?

Posted On: May 30, 2023
To get multiple keys, I sometimes drop hack.  Can I instead put a key in a capsule and have to get another key again? Question from user David West at gaming.stackexchange.com. Answer: ...[More]


Team Fortress 2 Bonus Points and How To Get Them Team Fortress 2 Bonus Points and How To Get Them

Posted On: June 11, 2023
Is there a comprehensive list of ways to earn bonus points in TF2?. I have seen here and there one way to do it with this class or the other, but there seems to be no complete list that I've fo...[More]


How do I know which version of Minecraft I have? How do I know which version of Minecraft I have?

Posted On: April 26, 2023
I don't know which version of Minecraft I have. I have regular Minecraft, not Java or anything else and I just don't know the version I have. Question from user Azalea at gaming.stackexchan...[More]