What is the Concerned Citizen in The Witcher 3?

[BACK]
What is the Concerned Citizen in The Witcher 3?
Posted On: June 8, 2023

In Novigrad I keep finding sheets of paper with messsages involving the "Eternal Fire" and Novigrad's church.


They seem to be written by someone who is against Magic, Witches, Mages and anything involving the Conjunction (pretty much like the talk you usually skip when starting the game).


I remember I once found a corpse in a road and Geralt said: "It wasn't Nathaniel. S••t" .


Nathaniel is Vegelbud's murderer that Geralt managed to track down and kill. Along with the corpse, another of those messages.


All of them are signed by a certain "Concerned Citizen" and are named "Concerned Citizen Sermon" when in the Inventory.


Apparently, they are even resellable!.


Now, who is this guy? Does he appear in the game or he's just a kind of Easter Egg?


Question from user Manchineel at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

This is part of the 'Carnal Sins' quest.


The Reverend Nathaniel is not in fact the serial killer, when you find him if you just go ahead and kill him immediately you have acted to hastily and you can no longer find the real killer.


When you do this you start to find these notes around Novigrad, they are telling you that the killer is still at large and you got the wrong person. .


Answer from user greg-449 at gaming.stackexchange.com.



[BACK]
What is the Concerned Citizen in The Witcher 3?
Posted On: June 8, 2023

In Novigrad I keep finding sheets of paper with messsages involving the "Eternal Fire" and Novigrad's church.


They seem to be written by someone who is against Magic, Witches, Mages and anything involving the Conjunction (pretty much like the talk you usually skip when starting the game).


I remember I once found a corpse in a road and Geralt said: "It wasn't Nathaniel. S••t" .


Nathaniel is Vegelbud's murderer that Geralt managed to track down and kill. Along with the corpse, another of those messages.


All of them are signed by a certain "Concerned Citizen" and are named "Concerned Citizen Sermon" when in the Inventory.


Apparently, they are even resellable!.


Now, who is this guy? Does he appear in the game or he's just a kind of Easter Egg?


Question from user Manchineel at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

This is part of the 'Carnal Sins' quest.


The Reverend Nathaniel is not in fact the serial killer, when you find him if you just go ahead and kill him immediately you have acted to hastily and you can no longer find the real killer.


When you do this you start to find these notes around Novigrad, they are telling you that the killer is still at large and you got the wrong person. .


Answer from user greg-449 at gaming.stackexchange.com.



[BACK]

Returnal Why cant I destroy this energy barrier with my melee attack? Returnal Why cant I destroy this energy barrier with my melee attack?

Posted On: May 4, 2023
This energy barrier doesn't appear to be any different than any of the other energy barriers I've destroyed (unless it's another colour blind issue), so I'm really confused as to why I...[More]


What do I do with Gale's bonus actions What do I do with Gale's bonus actions

Posted On: December 6, 2025
Feels like they just go to waste most of the time.Question from user psychorameses at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.Answer:Wizards just don’t make great use of the bonus action. There are some bonus ac...[More]


How do you make Cuphead black and white? How do you make Cuphead black and white?

Posted On: March 13, 2024
I've seen screenshots of it, and a character on the third isle says something about you have to be a pacifist or something. How is it done?Question from user Levi C. Olson at gaming.stackexchange.com....[More]


How is profit from gambling paid out? How is profit from gambling paid out?

Posted On: January 25, 2023
Normally, with a trade port, the payment for your wares shows up all few days when they sell.With gambling however, this is different. There is no direct payout as far as I can see and it is also not ...[More]


How do I forcefully duplicate a nether portal in Minecraft? How do I forcefully duplicate a nether portal in Minecraft?

Posted On: May 23, 2023
I've seen nether portals being duplicated due to linking problems before, but I can't seem to replicate that on purpose. I'm trying to create a sort of manual obsidian farm that doesn'...[More]


Defeating the helicopter in Split Second Defeating the helicopter in Split Second

Posted On: January 24, 2023
I'm having some trouble in the episode where you're supposed to defeat the helicopter. I do pretty well in the episodes where you're supposed to avoid the helicopter fire. I must be missing a power ...[More]


This happened when giving Karlach a soul coin in Act 3 This happened when giving Karlach a soul coin in Act 3

Posted On: November 13, 2025
I recently posted about a scene that happens if you have Karlach consume a soul coin after transforming into an Illithid. It was requested I provide a video, so after far too much frustration to get t...[More]


Can I disable DLC in Dead Cells? Can I disable DLC in Dead Cells?

Posted On: April 6, 2023
I purchased Dead Cells on Steam with all the DLC and am finding the experience to be overwhelming. Can I disable the DLC to only play with the original content? If yes, how would disabling the DLC imp...[More]


Whats the most efficient Minecraft mining strategy? Whats the most efficient Minecraft mining strategy?

Posted On: December 28, 2022
When I'm not exploring fresh caves or lands in minecraft, I'm busy trying to find deposits of diamond, gold and iron deep in the earth. So far I've just been digging around just above bedrock on a whi...[More]


how do i make a stick the runs - Tick freeze how do i make a stick the runs - Tick freeze

Posted On: March 8, 2024
I want to create a Za Warudo stick but I have searched on the internet for answers and found none.Can someone help?Question from user andreas senneset-søtorp at gaming.stackexchange.com.Answer:It is ...[More]