What is the Concerned Citizen in The Witcher 3?

[BACK]
What is the Concerned Citizen in The Witcher 3?
Posted On: June 8, 2023

In Novigrad I keep finding sheets of paper with messsages involving the "Eternal Fire" and Novigrad's church.


They seem to be written by someone who is against Magic, Witches, Mages and anything involving the Conjunction (pretty much like the talk you usually skip when starting the game).


I remember I once found a corpse in a road and Geralt said: "It wasn't Nathaniel. S••t" .


Nathaniel is Vegelbud's murderer that Geralt managed to track down and kill. Along with the corpse, another of those messages.


All of them are signed by a certain "Concerned Citizen" and are named "Concerned Citizen Sermon" when in the Inventory.


Apparently, they are even resellable!.


Now, who is this guy? Does he appear in the game or he's just a kind of Easter Egg?


Question from user Manchineel at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

This is part of the 'Carnal Sins' quest.


The Reverend Nathaniel is not in fact the serial killer, when you find him if you just go ahead and kill him immediately you have acted to hastily and you can no longer find the real killer.


When you do this you start to find these notes around Novigrad, they are telling you that the killer is still at large and you got the wrong person. .


Answer from user greg-449 at gaming.stackexchange.com.



[BACK]
What is the Concerned Citizen in The Witcher 3?
Posted On: June 8, 2023

In Novigrad I keep finding sheets of paper with messsages involving the "Eternal Fire" and Novigrad's church.


They seem to be written by someone who is against Magic, Witches, Mages and anything involving the Conjunction (pretty much like the talk you usually skip when starting the game).


I remember I once found a corpse in a road and Geralt said: "It wasn't Nathaniel. S••t" .


Nathaniel is Vegelbud's murderer that Geralt managed to track down and kill. Along with the corpse, another of those messages.


All of them are signed by a certain "Concerned Citizen" and are named "Concerned Citizen Sermon" when in the Inventory.


Apparently, they are even resellable!.


Now, who is this guy? Does he appear in the game or he's just a kind of Easter Egg?


Question from user Manchineel at gaming.stackexchange.com.


Answer:

This is part of the 'Carnal Sins' quest.


The Reverend Nathaniel is not in fact the serial killer, when you find him if you just go ahead and kill him immediately you have acted to hastily and you can no longer find the real killer.


When you do this you start to find these notes around Novigrad, they are telling you that the killer is still at large and you got the wrong person. .


Answer from user greg-449 at gaming.stackexchange.com.



[BACK]

Kagha arrange for Halsin's imprisonment? What was her plan? Kagha arrange for Halsin's imprisonment? What was her plan?

Posted On: December 29, 2024
[Spoilers].I figure she didn't, that she was already being seduced by the dark side of the Force, sorry wrong franchise, already being manipulated by the Shadow Druids, and when Halsin disappeared loo...[More]


Ehhhhh... I need help... Ehhhhh... I need help...

Posted On: April 24, 2024
I play on the highest difficulty so i have only one save. For a magic reason the game decide to auto save at this exact moment. Is there any way for me to not need to restart a new game? .https://prev...[More]


How can I copy part of a Minecraft world into another Minecraft world? How can I copy part of a Minecraft world into another Minecraft world?

Posted On: January 11, 2023
Backstory.The places that have been built on in my world aren't that big. It's a ~100x~100 square, a ~150x~50 rectangle in the Nether, and another ~100x~100 square accessed by portals.The world is cu...[More]


What is the Font Used in Pokemon Conquest? What is the Font Used in Pokemon Conquest?

Posted On: January 26, 2023
What's the font used in Pokemon Conquest's dialogue? More specifically, since I assume it's some proprietary font compiled in the game, where have I seen it before? It looked extremely familiar as soo...[More]


Mob Spawning - Despawning in Minecraft Mob Spawning - Despawning in Minecraft

Posted On: May 30, 2023
So I've been building up my Villager Trading farms and halls and breeders, etc., and one of these builds is the converter - Using a zombie to convert the villager and back again to reduce trade co...[More]


Who do you think your character would be after graduating Hogwarts? Who do you think your character would be after graduating Hogwarts?

Posted On: August 4, 2023
Mine would be either DADA teacher or an Auror. I know that there are limited options and probably your answers will be similar, but I'm curious what future would you see for your MC. Question f...[More]


How much health does an Apple heal? How much health does an Apple heal?

Posted On: January 20, 2023
How much HP does an apple heal? Whenever I pick up an apple the amount healed seems to vary. Does the amount healed scale with my character's maximum HP? Question from user Stevoisiak at gaming...[More]


How to get past the old man in Viridian City in Pokemon Leaf Green? How to get past the old man in Viridian City in Pokemon Leaf Green?

Posted On: March 20, 2024
It's been a while since I last played Pokémon Leaf green.I am playing it with my nephew and he asked me how to get to first Gym (Brock) to get the Boulder badge.Here is the problem:.An old man is lyi...[More]


Craziest take you've heard in the BG3 community? Craziest take you've heard in the BG3 community?

Posted On: June 14, 2025
I just saw someone argue unironically that Wyll is meaner than Astarion and Minthara.Question from user DearPersimmon8155 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.Answer:evil Durge murder hobo is actuelly the mo...[More]


Can you keep a piglin from turning into a zombified-piglin in the overworld? Can you keep a piglin from turning into a zombified-piglin in the overworld?

Posted On: March 2, 2023
Is it possible for you to keep a piglin unzombified in the overworld, whether it be through use of commands or otherwise? Question from user 12 rhombi in grid w no corners at gaming.stackexchange.c...[More]