This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...

[BACK]
This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...
Posted On: November 24, 2023

Full disclosure, I've never actually played D&D, but always wanted to. And I'm only about 5 hours into BG3.


With that out of the way. what the hell? Why does just about every non-basic ability require you to short/long rest before you can use it again? You're really telling me my trained Paladin can only hit people with the pommel of his sword once before he has to take a nap? And can only do that a max of 3 times a day? And my trained wizard can only cast like 2 spells before he needs to nap too?


I don't get the logic here. Some of these abilities feel really basic and even underpowered, yet they require me to rest which can only be done twice a day for short rests and requires lots of supplies for a long rest. What's the point of this? Why not just have a basic mana/stamina system that recharges over time without having to use arbitrarily limited rests?


I assume this is a thing in tabletop D&D, but it doesn't translate well to games at all.


Question from user Swordbreaker925 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.


Answer:

Because its a game mechanic in DnD. In BG3, you have unlimited resting anyway, and in fact a lot of story stuff is hidden behind long rests, so they just really went all-out on expecting you to spam that rest button.


Answer from user FluffyBunbunKittens at BaldursGate3 at reddit.



[BACK]
This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...
Posted On: November 24, 2023

Full disclosure, I've never actually played D&D, but always wanted to. And I'm only about 5 hours into BG3.


With that out of the way. what the hell? Why does just about every non-basic ability require you to short/long rest before you can use it again? You're really telling me my trained Paladin can only hit people with the pommel of his sword once before he has to take a nap? And can only do that a max of 3 times a day? And my trained wizard can only cast like 2 spells before he needs to nap too?


I don't get the logic here. Some of these abilities feel really basic and even underpowered, yet they require me to rest which can only be done twice a day for short rests and requires lots of supplies for a long rest. What's the point of this? Why not just have a basic mana/stamina system that recharges over time without having to use arbitrarily limited rests?


I assume this is a thing in tabletop D&D, but it doesn't translate well to games at all.


Question from user Swordbreaker925 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.


Answer:

Because its a game mechanic in DnD. In BG3, you have unlimited resting anyway, and in fact a lot of story stuff is hidden behind long rests, so they just really went all-out on expecting you to spam that rest button.


Answer from user FluffyBunbunKittens at BaldursGate3 at reddit.



[BACK]

Custom Biome by Y level minecraft datapack Custom Biome by Y level minecraft datapack

Posted On: January 16, 2023
I would like anywhere under y28 in the nether to be a custom biome called "nether_depths". I tried using code from the deep dark (since it only spawns deep in the world), but it does not see...[More]


How to move my save game to another PC in Raft? How to move my save game to another PC in Raft?

Posted On: February 21, 2023
I have a new PC and want to move my Raft saved game. Just copy/paste doesn't seem to work. I'm not using any digital platform or service. Question from user Juan Carlos Oropeza at gaming.st...[More]


Is there a way to respec attributes? Is there a way to respec attributes?

Posted On: October 25, 2023
I'm pretty sure there isn't a way-explicitly-offered-by-the-game to unset and reinvest health, stamina, and/or magicka advancements, but I'm also curious about exploits, console commands, ...[More]


Where in Skellige is this shipwreck located? Where in Skellige is this shipwreck located?

Posted On: October 5, 2023
I wanted to find a shipwreck in Witcher 3's Skellige for purposes of a Witcher Tabletop RPG campaign I'm playing, and I found these images of one:. While these images are nice, what they do...[More]


Can I change my house later in the game? Can I change my house later in the game?

Posted On: July 19, 2023
Once I've chosen my house, is it possible to change my house to a different house later in the game or do I need to start a new game? Like let's say I've chosen Slytherin as my starting...[More]


How did the cat end up in the city in Stray? How did the cat end up in the city in Stray?

Posted On: August 14, 2023
At the beginning of Stray, the cat is walking with his cat friends in nature presumably outside the city. How did the cat end up in the city at the beginning of the game if the city had been sealed? ...[More]


What's your favorite summoner? What's your favorite summoner?

Posted On: July 23, 2024
The ultimate power fantasy in gaming, getting your summons so strong you don't actually have to play the game. What's your favorite summoner setups? Multi or Mono, curious to see how others enjoy the ...[More]


Is this cheating in BG3 Honor Mode or fair game? Is this cheating in BG3 Honor Mode or fair game?

Posted On: August 27, 2025
I’m doing a Baldur’s Gate 3 Honor Mode run with three friends. We’ve made it all the way into Act 3 without glitches, cheese, or exploits — just raw pain and strategy.Here’s the problem: one...[More]


Does a physical copy of Batman: Arkham City Armored Edition need any extra install size on Wii U? Does a physical copy of Batman: Arkham City Armored Edition need any extra install size on Wii U?

Posted On: March 25, 2023
Does a physical copy of Batman: Arkham City Armored Edition need any extra install size on Wii U, and how much needed space it takes? . I'm asking because i want to get it but i only have left ...[More]


Can two players play a multiplayer game for Game Boy Advance using only one cartridge? Can two players play a multiplayer game for Game Boy Advance using only one cartridge?

Posted On: March 21, 2023
I have two Game Boy Advance units, each with a wireless link accessory. I also have only one copy of The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, The Witch, And The Wardrobe. I have tried to connect both units...[More]