This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...

[BACK]
This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...
Posted On: November 24, 2023

Full disclosure, I've never actually played D&D, but always wanted to. And I'm only about 5 hours into BG3.


With that out of the way. what the hell? Why does just about every non-basic ability require you to short/long rest before you can use it again? You're really telling me my trained Paladin can only hit people with the pommel of his sword once before he has to take a nap? And can only do that a max of 3 times a day? And my trained wizard can only cast like 2 spells before he needs to nap too?


I don't get the logic here. Some of these abilities feel really basic and even underpowered, yet they require me to rest which can only be done twice a day for short rests and requires lots of supplies for a long rest. What's the point of this? Why not just have a basic mana/stamina system that recharges over time without having to use arbitrarily limited rests?


I assume this is a thing in tabletop D&D, but it doesn't translate well to games at all.


Question from user Swordbreaker925 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.


Answer:

Because its a game mechanic in DnD. In BG3, you have unlimited resting anyway, and in fact a lot of story stuff is hidden behind long rests, so they just really went all-out on expecting you to spam that rest button.


Answer from user FluffyBunbunKittens at BaldursGate3 at reddit.



[BACK]
This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...
Posted On: November 24, 2023

Full disclosure, I've never actually played D&D, but always wanted to. And I'm only about 5 hours into BG3.


With that out of the way. what the hell? Why does just about every non-basic ability require you to short/long rest before you can use it again? You're really telling me my trained Paladin can only hit people with the pommel of his sword once before he has to take a nap? And can only do that a max of 3 times a day? And my trained wizard can only cast like 2 spells before he needs to nap too?


I don't get the logic here. Some of these abilities feel really basic and even underpowered, yet they require me to rest which can only be done twice a day for short rests and requires lots of supplies for a long rest. What's the point of this? Why not just have a basic mana/stamina system that recharges over time without having to use arbitrarily limited rests?


I assume this is a thing in tabletop D&D, but it doesn't translate well to games at all.


Question from user Swordbreaker925 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.


Answer:

Because its a game mechanic in DnD. In BG3, you have unlimited resting anyway, and in fact a lot of story stuff is hidden behind long rests, so they just really went all-out on expecting you to spam that rest button.


Answer from user FluffyBunbunKittens at BaldursGate3 at reddit.



[BACK]

Why don't I love my Dragonborn as I did my Argonians? Why don't I love my Dragonborn as I did my Argonians?

Posted On: March 22, 2026
I can't pinpoint what it is, but I had a fantastic time playing lizard people in Morrowind, Oblivion and Skyrim. It felt different, fun and interesting. The racial traits didn't matter to me - I just ...[More]


How to quit an online match? How to quit an online match?

Posted On: March 6, 2024
I'm trying to run for the Platinum trophy before the server closure, so I'll soon start to get game modes I don't need anymore, and I don't want to waste my time.Is there a way to leave an online matc...[More]


What Was Your Favorite Part of the Hogwarts Game? What Was Your Favorite Part of the Hogwarts Game?

Posted On: June 11, 2023
I LOVED Keeper Niamh's trail. When she initially said it may be familiar to a story I heard as a child, I about lost my mind. The Tale of Three Brothers is one of my favorite parts in the mo...[More]


What devices can you play Sonic Mania on? What devices can you play Sonic Mania on?

Posted On: January 24, 2023
I asked this question because Sonic Mania can probably be played on a few devices.Question from user Dark sonic at gaming.stackexchange.com.Answer:From the Wikipedia article on Sonic Mania, the game i...[More]


Why do my short beards look like crap? Why do my short beards look like crap?

Posted On: December 18, 2024
Question from user court_of_owlets at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.Answer:Reminds me of Team America :D.https: - - preview.redd.it - 84km4prjqm7e1.png?width=639&format=png&auto=webp&s=547e79da13e6e37970...[More]


What is the Eraser Trick in StarCraft? What is the Eraser Trick in StarCraft?

Posted On: July 4, 2023
What is the eraser trick mentioned in this StarCraft video? Note: This is referring to the 1998 game, not the current game. Question from user C. Ross at stackexchange. Answer: Here's ...[More]


Any tips for a new Hogwarts player? Any tips for a new Hogwarts player?

Posted On: July 9, 2023
No spoilers though please!. Question from user 5195cd at HogwartsLegacyGaming at reddit. Answer: Collect field pages this will help you to level up quickly. Use Revelio at all times. . ...[More]


This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense... This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...

Posted On: November 24, 2023
Full disclosure, I've never actually played D&D, but always wanted to. And I'm only about 5 hours into BG3. With that out of the way. what the hell? Why does just about every non-basic ...[More]


Is it possible to play Battlefront 2 with private servers? Is it possible to play Battlefront 2 with private servers?

Posted On: April 15, 2024
I recently purchased Star Wars: Battlefront 2 (2017, Celebration Edition), and I really enjoy playing online. However, I have encountered several hackers. Is there a way for me to setup a server I can...[More]


Anyone know how often the Hogwarts Express comes to the station? Anyone know how often the Hogwarts Express comes to the station?

Posted On: March 3, 2023
I’m getting in game screen shots and want a picture with the train. Question from user Giezho at HogwartsLegacyGaming at reddit.com. Answer: Best way to find it is to go to the train st...[More]