This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...

[BACK]
This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...
Posted On: November 24, 2023

Full disclosure, I've never actually played D&D, but always wanted to. And I'm only about 5 hours into BG3.


With that out of the way. what the hell? Why does just about every non-basic ability require you to short/long rest before you can use it again? You're really telling me my trained Paladin can only hit people with the pommel of his sword once before he has to take a nap? And can only do that a max of 3 times a day? And my trained wizard can only cast like 2 spells before he needs to nap too?


I don't get the logic here. Some of these abilities feel really basic and even underpowered, yet they require me to rest which can only be done twice a day for short rests and requires lots of supplies for a long rest. What's the point of this? Why not just have a basic mana/stamina system that recharges over time without having to use arbitrarily limited rests?


I assume this is a thing in tabletop D&D, but it doesn't translate well to games at all.


Question from user Swordbreaker925 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.


Answer:

Because its a game mechanic in DnD. In BG3, you have unlimited resting anyway, and in fact a lot of story stuff is hidden behind long rests, so they just really went all-out on expecting you to spam that rest button.


Answer from user FluffyBunbunKittens at BaldursGate3 at reddit.



[BACK]
This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...
Posted On: November 24, 2023

Full disclosure, I've never actually played D&D, but always wanted to. And I'm only about 5 hours into BG3.


With that out of the way. what the hell? Why does just about every non-basic ability require you to short/long rest before you can use it again? You're really telling me my trained Paladin can only hit people with the pommel of his sword once before he has to take a nap? And can only do that a max of 3 times a day? And my trained wizard can only cast like 2 spells before he needs to nap too?


I don't get the logic here. Some of these abilities feel really basic and even underpowered, yet they require me to rest which can only be done twice a day for short rests and requires lots of supplies for a long rest. What's the point of this? Why not just have a basic mana/stamina system that recharges over time without having to use arbitrarily limited rests?


I assume this is a thing in tabletop D&D, but it doesn't translate well to games at all.


Question from user Swordbreaker925 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.


Answer:

Because its a game mechanic in DnD. In BG3, you have unlimited resting anyway, and in fact a lot of story stuff is hidden behind long rests, so they just really went all-out on expecting you to spam that rest button.


Answer from user FluffyBunbunKittens at BaldursGate3 at reddit.



[BACK]

Why will she not take Panteas Flute? Why will she not take Panteas Flute?

Posted On: January 17, 2023
I found Pantea's Flute before the quest was given to me. Now she will not accept it from me, and it says I still need to go find it. What do I do now? Is this a glitch? I have the game on PC if th...[More]


Why did Donkey Kong 64 require more than 4 MB of memory? Why did Donkey Kong 64 require more than 4 MB of memory?

Posted On: August 1, 2023
As most of you know, the N64 Donkey Kong game had a game breaking bug on the 4 MB memory version. They needed to include the expansion memory just so that bug wouldn't happen. I can imagine in ...[More]


Is it possible to hold my wand in my left hand in Hogwarts Legacy? Is it possible to hold my wand in my left hand in Hogwarts Legacy?

Posted On: July 19, 2023
By default, my character is right handed and holds the wand in his right hand. Is there a way I can change my character to be left handed and hold the wand in my left hand? Question from user Sh...[More]


How can I turn a rare item into a rare magic item? How can I turn a rare item into a rare magic item?

Posted On: October 23, 2023
I turned a silk vest into a rare, and then later found that I could not change it into a magic item, because it isn't normal. . Is there a way to turn a rare item into a magic item? . It was...[More]


How do I transfer wares for a mission in X4 Foundations? How do I transfer wares for a mission in X4 Foundations?

Posted On: September 1, 2023
How do I transfer wares to finish a mission? I'm docked at the correct ship, but transfer wares is disabled in the menu. I'm at the correct ship:. And I have the antimatter cells in m...[More]


Redstone door lock (memory cell) Redstone door lock (memory cell)

Posted On: March 30, 2024
I want to make a pvp map which has 2 spawnpoints on the map. The spawnpoints are closed off with an iron door. The teams can both get ready by flipping a lever. Now i want to make it so when both team...[More]


Couldn't play at release,, I can finally commit. Pick my MC! Couldn't play at release,, I can finally commit. Pick my MC!

Posted On: January 9, 2026
Nothing too wild or difficult, I haven't played a crpg in a while. But I did play old school AD&D way back. What should I roll for my first proper playthrough?Question from user Killroyjones at Baldur...[More]


How to make the event sound from share button louder? How to make the event sound from share button louder?

Posted On: May 15, 2023
I have a little problem finding something in the settings. I want to make the event sound louder when I take a screenshot over the share button since I can barely hear it. Is it possible to adjust ...[More]


Command to say player coords in chat? Command to say player coords in chat?

Posted On: January 28, 2023
Trying to get a command that tells a player's coords in chat. I have a working command: /data get entity @s Pos, but I assume I would need to combine this with /tellraw?Question from user Aceplante at...[More]


Mass Effect 3 Where is this terminal? Mass Effect 3 Where is this terminal?

Posted On: May 3, 2023
I have to activate the terminal for the Hanar Diplomat quest, but I can't seem to find it? The only terminal I can find in the security checkpoint area (I'm standing next to it on the map) can...[More]