This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...

[BACK]
This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...
Posted On: November 24, 2023

Full disclosure, I've never actually played D&D, but always wanted to. And I'm only about 5 hours into BG3.


With that out of the way. what the hell? Why does just about every non-basic ability require you to short/long rest before you can use it again? You're really telling me my trained Paladin can only hit people with the pommel of his sword once before he has to take a nap? And can only do that a max of 3 times a day? And my trained wizard can only cast like 2 spells before he needs to nap too?


I don't get the logic here. Some of these abilities feel really basic and even underpowered, yet they require me to rest which can only be done twice a day for short rests and requires lots of supplies for a long rest. What's the point of this? Why not just have a basic mana/stamina system that recharges over time without having to use arbitrarily limited rests?


I assume this is a thing in tabletop D&D, but it doesn't translate well to games at all.


Question from user Swordbreaker925 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.


Answer:

Because its a game mechanic in DnD. In BG3, you have unlimited resting anyway, and in fact a lot of story stuff is hidden behind long rests, so they just really went all-out on expecting you to spam that rest button.


Answer from user FluffyBunbunKittens at BaldursGate3 at reddit.



[BACK]
This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...
Posted On: November 24, 2023

Full disclosure, I've never actually played D&D, but always wanted to. And I'm only about 5 hours into BG3.


With that out of the way. what the hell? Why does just about every non-basic ability require you to short/long rest before you can use it again? You're really telling me my trained Paladin can only hit people with the pommel of his sword once before he has to take a nap? And can only do that a max of 3 times a day? And my trained wizard can only cast like 2 spells before he needs to nap too?


I don't get the logic here. Some of these abilities feel really basic and even underpowered, yet they require me to rest which can only be done twice a day for short rests and requires lots of supplies for a long rest. What's the point of this? Why not just have a basic mana/stamina system that recharges over time without having to use arbitrarily limited rests?


I assume this is a thing in tabletop D&D, but it doesn't translate well to games at all.


Question from user Swordbreaker925 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.


Answer:

Because its a game mechanic in DnD. In BG3, you have unlimited resting anyway, and in fact a lot of story stuff is hidden behind long rests, so they just really went all-out on expecting you to spam that rest button.


Answer from user FluffyBunbunKittens at BaldursGate3 at reddit.



[BACK]

How To Spawn after a specific amount of time How To Spawn after a specific amount of time

Posted On: January 27, 2023
I am currently making a Legend of Zelda themed adventure map. I am struggling to make it, so enemies spawn every few minutes but not spawn large amounts over time. I have tried using things like hoppe...[More]


OpenTTD: Invading a city to get a rail line through it OpenTTD: Invading a city to get a rail line through it

Posted On: March 18, 2024
How do I keep local authorities off my back long enough to destroy and terraform part of their beautiful city so my megaconglomeration can inject its horrible, pollution-causing railway station right ...[More]


How do I find the missing Gold Skulltulas? How do I find the missing Gold Skulltulas?

Posted On: August 5, 2023
I've almost completely finished Ocarina of Time now, and I'd like to get 100% completion just for the fun of it. The big problem is the Gold Skulltulas. I've heard there's some sort...[More]


In Hogwarts how do I unlock chests with an eyeball on it? In Hogwarts how do I unlock chests with an eyeball on it?

Posted On: February 14, 2023
I have come across multiple chests that will not let me open them. They have an eye in the middle which looks at me when I get close. Question from user Oast at gaming.stackexchange.com. Answer:...[More]


Help? Dark urge question Help? Dark urge question

Posted On: November 13, 2023
So I've told everyone I'm not becoming Bhaals chosen, killed Orins grandfather/father and killed Orin and then did a long rest, got told by the butler that I would become a mindless killer eve...[More]


Can anyone explain how time works in this game? Can anyone explain how time works in this game?

Posted On: November 16, 2023
So I had an issue early on that's kinda ruined my experience. When I found the gith woman locked in the cage, I talked the tieflings into moving, but then I couldn't figure out how to target t...[More]


Do the tiles in Bounce n Trounce fall in a random order? Do the tiles in Bounce n Trounce fall in a random order?

Posted On: October 17, 2023
In the minigame Bounce 'n' Trounce, do the floor tiles fall away in a random order? Or is there a predetermined order every time? Question from user Stevoisiak at stackexchange. Answer: ...[More]


Hogwarts Legacy Explanations Hogwarts Legacy Explanations

Posted On: June 6, 2023
Hey my first time posting on here so not sure of the usual etiquette but spoilers ahead!. I’ve got some frustrations with Hogwarts Legacy and it’s ending and wanted to vent maybe even p...[More]


My Arabella cosplay My Arabella cosplay

Posted On: July 24, 2024
Question from user FridaAih at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com.Answer:Don’t go stealing any idols, or your mom will feed you to a gnoll.Answer from user Tavminater at BaldursGate3 at reddit.com....[More]


Trying to Play an Old Game, will Installing Old Direct X Affect Anything? Trying to Play an Old Game, will Installing Old Direct X Affect Anything?

Posted On: May 25, 2023
I'm trying to play an old Windows 98 game on Windows 7. The game is asking me to install DirectX 6. If I choose to install them will this affect my system? (In other words will this stop new...[More]