This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...

[BACK]
This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...
Posted On: November 24, 2023

Full disclosure, I've never actually played D&D, but always wanted to. And I'm only about 5 hours into BG3.


With that out of the way. what the hell? Why does just about every non-basic ability require you to short/long rest before you can use it again? You're really telling me my trained Paladin can only hit people with the pommel of his sword once before he has to take a nap? And can only do that a max of 3 times a day? And my trained wizard can only cast like 2 spells before he needs to nap too?


I don't get the logic here. Some of these abilities feel really basic and even underpowered, yet they require me to rest which can only be done twice a day for short rests and requires lots of supplies for a long rest. What's the point of this? Why not just have a basic mana/stamina system that recharges over time without having to use arbitrarily limited rests?


I assume this is a thing in tabletop D&D, but it doesn't translate well to games at all.


Question from user Swordbreaker925 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.


Answer:

Because its a game mechanic in DnD. In BG3, you have unlimited resting anyway, and in fact a lot of story stuff is hidden behind long rests, so they just really went all-out on expecting you to spam that rest button.


Answer from user FluffyBunbunKittens at BaldursGate3 at reddit.



[BACK]
This short - long rest thing is annoying and makes no sense...
Posted On: November 24, 2023

Full disclosure, I've never actually played D&D, but always wanted to. And I'm only about 5 hours into BG3.


With that out of the way. what the hell? Why does just about every non-basic ability require you to short/long rest before you can use it again? You're really telling me my trained Paladin can only hit people with the pommel of his sword once before he has to take a nap? And can only do that a max of 3 times a day? And my trained wizard can only cast like 2 spells before he needs to nap too?


I don't get the logic here. Some of these abilities feel really basic and even underpowered, yet they require me to rest which can only be done twice a day for short rests and requires lots of supplies for a long rest. What's the point of this? Why not just have a basic mana/stamina system that recharges over time without having to use arbitrarily limited rests?


I assume this is a thing in tabletop D&D, but it doesn't translate well to games at all.


Question from user Swordbreaker925 at BaldursGate3 at reddit.


Answer:

Because its a game mechanic in DnD. In BG3, you have unlimited resting anyway, and in fact a lot of story stuff is hidden behind long rests, so they just really went all-out on expecting you to spam that rest button.


Answer from user FluffyBunbunKittens at BaldursGate3 at reddit.



[BACK]

Can you play the entire game solo? Can you play the entire game solo?

Posted On: May 28, 2024
Just curious. It seems like it would be impossible with some of the fights but I wonder if it can be done. Like you just use tav and leave all your companions at camp every day?Question from user glit...[More]


In Dantes Inferno, What gameplay differences are there between the Holy and Unholy tree? In Dantes Inferno, What gameplay differences are there between the Holy and Unholy tree?

Posted On: March 25, 2023
I just started playing this game, and I'm wondering what differences there are in gameplay between the Holy and Unholy trees. Does either tree have powers that are unique in functionality to each ...[More]


In Dead Cells Does hitting bells in the Clock Tower do anything? In Dead Cells Does hitting bells in the Clock Tower do anything?

Posted On: April 8, 2023
In the Clock Tower there are bells I can hit to make a ringing noise and a a visible wave. It doesn't seem to have any effect on enemies. Is there any purpose to hitting these bells? Question f...[More]


Is shoving enemies supposed to make you an oath breaker? Is shoving enemies supposed to make you an oath breaker?

Posted On: June 9, 2025
I'm confused. Got into a conflict in act one with zarys and her goons. They initiate combat and my paladin shoved one of them off a cliff. Immediate oathbreaker. I reloaded and just killed them normal...[More]


BG3 Rites of Passage BG3 Rites of Passage

Posted On: April 18, 2026
In another thread about using Divine Intervention again Raphael, and finding out that’s a very bad idea if you’re unprepared, several people posted some variation of “It happens to everyone at l...[More]


Do enemies only drop food after beating the game? Do enemies only drop food after beating the game?

Posted On: October 17, 2023
I've never seen enemies drop food until I started Loitering. Were those drops unlocked by beating the game / seeing the credits? And is it only because I'm Loitering, instead of going to Ne...[More]


Do you consider saving Shadowheart parents a good choice? Do you consider saving Shadowheart parents a good choice?

Posted On: November 3, 2023
On my first playthrough, I killed them because it seemed like the best choice. I'm on my second playthrough now and this time, I choose to romance Shadowheart. I'm at that point where I need t...[More]


is there a Clothing shop in Baldur's gate? is there a Clothing shop in Baldur's gate?

Posted On: October 28, 2023
Im looking for some cool camp clothing. . Im lying, im looking for underwear. I just got to Act 3, Rivington to be exact. Can someone point me to the right direction please? Asking for myself. Or a...[More]


How much Gold would Zevlor have given me for killing the Goblins? How much Gold would Zevlor have given me for killing the Goblins?

Posted On: November 11, 2023
After defeating a camp of goblins and returning to Emerald Cove, I was greeted by the Tiefling Zevlor. He thanked me for killing the Goblins so they could safely travel to Baldur's Gate. He said h...[More]


I’m getting bored in Hogwarts Legacy I’m getting bored in Hogwarts Legacy

Posted On: August 8, 2023
I’ve been waiting for this game since 2021 when it got announced and was honestly so hyped, but now I’m getting insanely bored. I got the game 3 months ago, then played for 26 hours total,...[More]